Make a guess about the past
I can suggest what happened and judge someone's decision with hindsight.
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Grammar
17 minIn B1 #10 you made guesses about the present: He must be at home — his car is outside. But more often we guess about what has already happened: where the parcel has gone, why a colleague didn't come. Modal verbs have no past form for a guess, so in a guess the past is carried by have with the third form: He must have left. It is the same have that moved would into the past in would have (B2 #4).
The form: modal verb + have + the third form. have does not change for any person.
| positive | She must have left early. |
| negative | He can't have seen us. / They might not have heard the bell. |
| question | Could she have taken the wrong bus? |
| continuous | He must have been sleeping — he didn't hear the phone. |
| passive | The parcel must have been delivered next door. |
The first meaning — a guess about the past. The scale is the same as in B1 #10, only about what has already happened:
| form | how sure | example |
|---|---|---|
| must have | almost sure it happened | Her coat is gone — she must have left. |
| may have / might have / could have | perhaps it happened | They might have missed the train. |
| may not have / might not have | perhaps it didn't happen | She may not have got my message. |
| can't have / couldn't have | almost sure it didn't happen | He can't have known — nobody told him. |
The continuous form must have been doing is a guess about a process that was going on at that moment, like must be doing about the present (B1 #10). The passive must have been done is for when something was done to a thing: the parcel was delivered, the window was broken, and who did it doesn't matter or isn't known.
The evidence is usually named next to the guess, as in the present: The streets are wet — it must have rained in the night. In a question, use could: Could he have forgotten? — "Is it possible that he forgot?"
The second meaning — judging with hindsight. Here the speaker knows what happened and judges it:
| form | meaning | example |
|---|---|---|
| should have | it was the right thing to do, but it wasn't done | You should have called me. |
| shouldn't have | it was the wrong thing to do, but it was done | I shouldn't have said that. |
| could have | there was a chance, but it wasn't used | You could have told me! |
| needn't have | it was done, but it wasn't necessary | You needn't have waited — I had a key. |
should have changes its shade with the person: You should have told me is a reproach, I should have told you is a regret, almost the same as I wish I had told you (B2 #8). could have in a reproach sounds sharper: "you could have, but you didn't bother". In British speech You might have warned me! sounds the same way — it is a reproach, not a guess.
could have has two meanings, and the situation tells them apart. It could have been Tom is a guess: I don't know who it was, perhaps Tom. You could have been killed! is about something that did not happen: you could have died, but you didn't. If we know that the event did not happen, we use could have or might have, not may have.
needn't — "it is not necessary". To understand needn't have, first look at needn't itself. It is the same as don't need to (B1 #11): there is no need; you can do it, but you don't have to. You needn't come tomorrow = You don't need to come tomorrow. Unlike don't need to, needn't is a modal verb: no to, no do, one form for all persons: She needn't worry. We needn't hurry. It is a British form, and it lives almost only in the negative: in a positive sentence people say You need to call him — an ordinary verb with to, and in a question Do I need to call him? Compare it with a prohibition: You needn't tell him — you don't have to tell him; You mustn't tell him — you are not allowed to tell him.
needn't have against didn't need to. The past of needn't is built in the same way as with the other modals: needn't have + the third form. And next to it stands the familiar didn't need to. Both seem to say "it wasn't necessary", but English keeps them apart:
| I needn't have gone — the meeting was cancelled. | I went, and it was a waste of time |
| I didn't need to go — the meeting was cancelled. | there was no need; whether I went or not is not said |
| I needn't have cooked so much — half of it was left. | I cooked, and it was a waste |
| I didn't need to cook — we went out to eat. | it wasn't necessary; here it is clear that I didn't cook |
needn't have always means that the thing was done, and the effort turned out to be unnecessary. didn't need to only says that there was no necessity. Whether the person did it or not is shown by the rest of the sentence, and most often they didn't: I didn't need to wait, so I went home.
Compare couldn't have and couldn't: He couldn't have done it — "it is impossible that he did it"; He couldn't do it — "he was not able to do it".
More examples:
| You must have been exhausted after the flight. | I'm sure you were very tired. |
| I may have left my keys at work. | Perhaps I left my keys at work. |
| She can't have finished already — she only started an hour ago. | It's impossible that she has finished already. |
| We shouldn't have booked such a cheap hotel. | Booking such a cheap hotel was a mistake. |
Don't say this. ✗ They may have went home → ✓ They may have gone home. After have — only the third form, as in would have (B2 #4). ✗ You needn't to worry → ✓ You needn't worry: after a modal there is no to. ✗ She must had left → ✓ She must have left: the past is carried by have, not by had. ✗ He mustn't have known → ✓ He can't have known: mustn't is only a prohibition, and "almost certainly not" is can't have. I must have called the bank means "I probably called the bank", not "it was my duty to call the bank"; about a duty people say I should have called the bank (but I didn't) or I had to call the bank (and I did).
Check yourself. You are almost sure that he missed the train: how do you say it? The street is dry. What do you say about rain in the night — must have rained or can't have rained? You took a taxi, and then it turned out that a friend had come to pick you up. How do you say that taking the taxi was unnecessary?
show the answers
Common learner errors
written for your languagemustn't have in a guess
✗ He mustn't have known
✓ He can't have known
The natural negative of must seems to be mustn't, and the mistake from B1 #10 comes back in the past. But in British English mustn't is a prohibition, and a guess "almost certainly not" is can't have. In American English must not have is also heard in this meaning; this course follows British usage.
must have as "had to"
I must have called the bank means "I probably called the bank", not "I had to call it". If you meant a duty, you need ✓ I had to call the bank (and I did) or ✓ I should have called the bank (but I didn't). French j'ai dû appeler la banque means both "I had to call" and "I must have called", and learners carry this over. But must have keeps only the meaning of a guess.
No have
✗ You should told me → ✓ You should have told me; ✗ She must had left → ✓ She must have left. It is tempting to show the past on the verb itself. But after a modal verb comes only the base form, and the past is carried by have, not by had.
needn't have and didn't need to mixed up
Both are often translated with the same words "it wasn't necessary", but I needn't have waited means "I waited, and it was a waste", and I didn't need to wait — usually "I didn't wait: there was no need". Choose by what really happened.
needn't and mustn't mixed up
German Du musst es ihm nicht sagen means "you don't have to tell him", and German speakers often say You mustn't tell him in this meaning — but in English that is a ban. And the other way round: You needn't tell him is not a mistake, but it means "you don't have to". If you meant "don't tell him, it's not allowed", you need ✓ You mustn't tell him. needn't is freedom, mustn't is a ban.
Pronunciation
4 minhave after a modal shrinks to /əv/ and merges with it into one word:
| must have | /ˈmʌstəv/ |
| should have | /ˈʃʊdəv/ |
| could have | /ˈkʊdəv/ |
| might have | /ˈmaɪtəv/ |
| can't have | /ˈkɑːntəv/ |
| needn't have | /ˈniːdntəv/ |
needn't itself is /ˈniːdnt/: /d/ goes straight into /n/ without a vowel, and the final /t/ is hardly heard. The /n/ at the end helps you tell needn't from need by ear: You needn't wait /jə ˈniːdn ˈweɪt/.
This is the same reduction as in would have (B2 #4), and it leads to the same written mistake, made even by native speakers: should of, must of. It is useful to recognise it, but never write it.
In a guess the stress is on the main verb: She must have LEFT. In a reproach — on the modal: You SHOULD have told me. You COULD have called! The voice falls sharply on it.
Text
6 minWhen I got home on Tuesday, there was no sign of the parcel I'd been waiting for all week. The tracking app said it had been delivered at 2.15, but there was nothing on the doorstep.
My first thought was that somebody must have stolen it. Then I noticed a card on the mat: "Sorry we missed you." So the courier must have come to the house. But he can't have rung the bell — my partner was working upstairs all afternoon and didn't hear a thing. My partner might have had his headphones on, of course. Or the courier may not have rung at all: apparently, some of them just leave a card and drive off.
The card said the parcel had been left "in a safe place". I looked in the bin, behind the plants and under the car. Nothing. It couldn't have gone far, I thought. In the end I tried the neighbours. Mrs Patel at number twelve had it: she must have heard the van and gone out to take it in.
Looking back, I should have asked her first — she takes in parcels for half the street. And I needn't have searched the bin in the rain. My partner, of course, says I could have just called the delivery company. He's right. But he could also have opened the door when the courier came.
Exercises
35 min1. Gap fill. A guess about the past: must have, can't have or might have.
- Her coat isn't here — she (leave) already
- He (see) us — he would have said hello
- I'm not sure where Jo is. She (go) to the gym
- The ground is dry, so it (rain) last night
- You (be) tired after such a long drive
- They're not answering. They (not / hear) the phone
- The window is broken — somebody (break) in
- He didn't answer the phone because he (sleep). (continuous form)
Show the answers
2. Multiple choice: should have, shouldn't have, needn't have or didn't need to?
- I (buy) so much bread — half of it went stale
- You (tell) me about the problem earlier — I could have helped
- We (book) a table — the restaurant was empty, so we just walked in
- I (eat) that second pizza. I feel terrible
- You (bring) an umbrella — it didn't rain all day
- The taxi was already paid for, so I (pay) the driver
Show the answers
3. Rewrite with needn't. The meaning is "you don't have to".
- You don't need to bring anything — we've got plenty of food.
- It isn't necessary for you to wait for me.
- She doesn't need to worry about the exam — she's well prepared.
Show the answers
4. Rewrite as a guess with a modal verb.
- I'm sure she forgot about the meeting.
- Perhaps they missed the train.
- I'm sure he didn't read my email.
- It's possible that the parcel was delivered next door.
- I'm certain that you were exhausted after the flight.
- Maybe she didn't get my message.
Show the answers
5. Expand the prompt into a judgement with hindsight: one sentence with the word in brackets.
- He didn't save the file, and he lost everything. (should)
- She left the door unlocked. Someone stole her bike. (shouldn't)
- You knew I was ill, but you didn't call. (could — a reproach)
- I didn't check the timetable, so we missed the last bus. (should)
- We paid for express delivery, but the parcel came at the normal time anyway. (needn't)
Show the answers
6. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.
- He mustn't have known about the meeting.
- You should told me earlier.
- She must had left before we arrived.
- They may have went home already.
- I must have called the bank yesterday, but I forgot. (it was my duty to call)
- You should of asked me first.
Show the answers
7. Say it in English.
Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence, with the forms of this lesson. 1) You are almost sure that he missed the train. 2) You are sure she didn't say that, because she was in London at the time. 3) Your friend didn't warn you, and that was wrong. Tell them. 4) You cooked a lot of food, but nobody came, so all that cooking was unnecessary. 5) Your friend had a chance to help you but didn't. Complain.
Show the answers
8. Answer in full sentences.
Explain three mysteries with guesses, two for each. The answers below are an example. 1) Your colleague didn't come to work and isn't answering the phone. What might have happened? 2) You come home and the kitchen window is open. You're sure you closed it. What could have happened? 3) A friend arrived at your party two hours late and very wet. What must have happened?
Show the answers
Summary
Covered: modal verb + have + the third form in all its forms, the scale of guesses about the past, judging with hindsight with should have, could have, needn't have, the two meanings of could have, needn't + verb against mustn't, needn't have against didn't need to, can't have instead of mustn't have, must have — not "had to". Next — lesson 10: how likely something is.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Vocabulary for your deck
16 words- needn't /ˈniːdnt/ don't have to; it is not necessary
- no sign of /nəʊ ˈsaɪn əv/ nothing that shows that something is there
- doorstep /ˈdɔːstep/ the step just outside the front door of a house
- courier /ˈkʊriə/ a person whose job is to deliver parcels
- ring the bell /ˌrɪŋ ðə ˈbel/ to press the button at the door so that it rings
- headphones /ˈhedfəʊnz/ small speakers that you wear over your ears
- apparently /əˈpærəntli/ it seems, from what people say
- drive off /ˌdraɪv ˈɒf/ to leave in a car or a van
- bin /bɪn/ a container for rubbish
- take in /ˌteɪk ˈɪn/ to accept a parcel for someone else
- looking back /ˌlʊkɪŋ ˈbæk/ thinking now about something in the past
- stale /steɪl/ (about bread) old and dry, no longer fresh
- unlocked /ʌnˈlɒkt/ not locked
- express delivery /ɪkˌspres dɪˈlɪvəri/ a faster delivery that costs more
- blow open /ˌbləʊ ˈəʊpən/ (about the wind) to open a door or a window by blowing
- be taken ill /bi ˌteɪkən ˈɪl/ to become ill suddenly
Writing
Eight to ten sentences — a look back at a day that went wrong: what went wrong, three or four guesses about why, and three judgements — what should have been done differently and what you did for nothing.
Example
Last Friday our team presentation went badly. The projector didn't work, so somebody must have changed the settings after the last meeting. It can't have been Mark — he was on holiday all week. The cleaners might have unplugged it. I should have tested everything the evening before. We shouldn't have left the slides on one laptop, either. Anna could have brought a copy, but nobody asked her to. And I needn't have printed fifty handouts: only twelve people came.
Checklist
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional