Tricky point ~47 min of the core left

Review 1 (lessons 1–5)

Start the lesson Core 47 min · steps: 3 · optional: +1

Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.

Tricky point

12 min

In English who has an object form — whom, just as he has him. Once it was used everywhere the person was not the subject. Today it lives in two places: right after a preposition and in formal writing. In ordinary speech it is almost always replaced by who or by nothing at all.

One idea — three styles:

the man to whom I spoke formal: letters, reports, contracts
the man who I spoke to ordinary speech
the man I spoke to the most common
To whom it may concern a fixed formula at the start of a letter when you don't know who will read it

The main rule: right after a preposition — only whom. Neither who nor that goes after a preposition: ✗ the man to who I spoke, ✗ the man to that I spoke. If the preposition moves to the end (B1 #17), whom turns into who or disappears altogether: the colleague with whom I share an office → the colleague I share an office with.

Without a preposition whom is possible, but it sounds bookish: the candidate whom we interviewed — this is how people write in a report; in conversation they say the candidate (who) we interviewed.

In questions whom is even rarer. Who did you see? is a normal question, Whom did you see? sounds old-fashioned. With a preposition at the start only whom is left: To whom should I send the form? — formal; Who should I send the form to? — ordinary. If you are not sure, and the preposition is not right next to the word, use who: in conversation it is always fine, while an unnecessary whom sounds stiff, as if you were reading a contract aloud.

Why whom is disappearing. English has almost no cases left: nouns have none at all, and pronouns have only pairs like he — him, they — them. who — whom belongs to the same group, but this pair stands at the start of a clause or a question, where English by habit expects a subject, and who has pushed whom out almost everywhere. whom has held on only where a neighbouring word supports it: a preposition, or of after a word of quantity. So what you need to learn is not "where whom is possible", but "where you can't do without it". There are two such places: right after a preposition and after of in phrases like both of whom.

The he and him test. If him fits in the place of the word, whom works; if he fits, only who. the man who called you — he called you, so who. the man whom you called — you called him, so whom (or, more simply, who, or nothing). Hence a common mistake by people who try to write "more correctly": ✗ the woman whom called you. whom never works as the subject.

some of whom, both of whom, none of whom. In a non-defining clause (with a comma), after words of quantity only whom is used, and it can't be replaced by who:

I have two brothers, both of whom live abroad. the two of them live abroad
Thirty people applied, most of whom had no experience. the majority of them
She invited ten friends, none of whom came. not one of them came

Don't say this. ✗ I have two brothers, both of them live abroad → ✓ I have two brothers, both of whom live abroad — or two sentences: I have two brothers. Both of them live abroad. them seems natural here, but then two sentences are glued together with just a comma, and English does not allow that.

Check yourself. How can you say this more simply: the colleague with whom I share an office? Do you need whom in the woman ___ called you? How do you finish: She has three sisters, all of ___ are doctors?

show the answers
the colleague I share an office with / the colleague who I share an office with; no — she is the subject, so you need who: the woman who called you; whom: all of whom are doctors.
Advertisement

Exercises on lessons 1–5

35 min

1. Mixed gap fill. Put the verbs into the right form.

  1. The ground was wet — it (rain) all night
  2. I (call) you last night, but I fell asleep — I intended to
  3. By Friday I (finish) the report
  4. If I (know) about the delay, I (take) the earlier train
  5. If I (study) medicine, I (be) a doctor now
  6. She was exhausted because she (work) since six
  7. He promised that he (send) the numbers by Wednesday
  8. At eight tomorrow I (fly) to Rome, so don't call
  9. If she (be) more patient, she (not / shout) at him yesterday
  10. By the time you (get) here, we (leave)
Show the answers
had been raining; was going to call; will have finished; had known / would have taken; had studied / would be; had been working; would send; will be flying; were / was / had been, wouldn't have shouted; get / will have left

2. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.

  1. She had been reading three chapters before dinner.
  2. He promised he will call me on Monday, but he never did.
  3. I'll have finished the report until Friday.
  4. If I would have known, I would have called you.
  5. If I had studied medicine, I would have been a doctor now.
  6. When I met her, she has been living in Paris for a year.
  7. The man to who I spoke was very helpful.
  8. I have two sisters, both of them live in York.
Show the answers
She had read three chapters before dinner; He promised he would call me on Monday, but he never did; I'll have finished the report by Friday; If I had known, I would have called you; If I had studied medicine, I would be a doctor now; When I met her, she had been living in Paris for a year; The man to whom I spoke was very helpful / The man who I spoke to was very helpful / The man I spoke to was very helpful; I have two sisters, both of whom live in York

3. Rewrite formally: put the preposition before whom.

  1. The man I spoke to was very helpful.
  2. The colleague I share an office with is on holiday.
  3. Who did you give the keys to?
  4. The people we work for are very demanding.
Show the answers
The man to whom I spoke was very helpful; The colleague with whom I share an office is on holiday; To whom did you give the keys?; The people for whom we work are very demanding

4. Join two sentences with of whom.

  1. I have two brothers. + Both of them live abroad.
  2. Thirty people applied. + Most of them had no experience.
  3. She invited ten friends. + None of them came.
Show the answers
I have two brothers, both of whom live abroad; Thirty people applied, most of whom had no experience; She invited ten friends, none of whom came

5. Matching. Form → meaning.

  1. was about to
  2. will have finished
  3. had been waiting
  4. would have called
Show the answers
was about to — on the point of doing it; will have finished — done no later than the deadline; had been waiting — the waiting went on up to that moment; would have called — a call in the unreal past (it didn't happen)

6. Rewrite following the prompt in brackets.

  1. I intended to call you. I forgot. (was going to … but)
  2. I'll finish it on Thursday. (by Friday)
  3. I didn't know. I didn't come. (third conditional)
  4. I didn't take that job. I'm not in Berlin now. (mixed conditional)
  5. They started waiting at nine. The bus came at ten. (had been waiting … when)
Show the answers
I was going to call you, but I forgot; I'll have finished it by Friday / I will have finished it by Friday; If I had known, I would have come; If I had taken that job, I would be in Berlin now; They had been waiting for an hour when the bus came / They had been waiting since nine when the bus came

7. Say it in English.

Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it with the forms of lessons 1–5. 1) They started waiting at six. We arrived at eight. Describe the moment of our arrival. 2) You planned to tell your friend something, but there wasn't enough time, so you didn't. 3) The work on our house will be complete no later than the end of the month. Say it, looking back from the end of the month. 4) I didn't know, so I didn't come earlier. Connect the two. 5) Years ago I moved to London, and that is why I know you today. Connect the two.

Show the answers
When we arrived, they had been waiting for two hours / They had been waiting for two hours when we arrived; I was going to tell you, but I didn't have time / I was going to tell you, but I ran out of time; By the end of the month we'll have finished the renovation / We'll have finished the work on the house by the end of the month / We'll have finished the renovation by the end of the month / By the end of the month we'll finish the renovation / We'll finish the renovation by the end of the month / We'll finish the work on the house by the end of the month; If I had known, I would have come earlier; If I hadn't moved to London, I wouldn't know you
Advertisement

Summary

Covered

  • lessons 1–5 in full and whom — after a preposition
  • in a formal style
  • in some of whom
  • both of whom
  • none of whom

Next — lesson 7: the terms of a contract.

End of the core

The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.

Lesson 115

optional

Mini production

Talk aloud and then write down ten sentences: a long story about a day that went wrong. You need a long action in the background, an intention that did not come true, a deadline in the future, one third conditional and one mixed one. At least one sentence with whom after a preposition or with some of whom, both of whom.

Checklist before lesson 7:

  • a long action in the background — had been + -ing, but with a number the simple form?
  • an intention that did not come true — was going to, a promise from the past — would, not will?
  • a deadline in the future — by and will have + the third form, a length of time — until?
  • in the third conditional, after if — the Past Perfect, would have — only in the main part?
  • in the mixed type, was each half chosen by its own "when"?
  • after a preposition — whom, not who or that?
The draft is saved on this device

Got a feature idea?

Send idea
Advertisement
Advertisement