Tell a long story
I can tell a story where four past tenses work together, and the listener does not lose the thread.
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Grammar
16 minIn B1 you put three past tenses together in one story (B1 #2): the Past Simple moves the plot, the Past Continuous paints the background, the Past Perfect takes a step back. In the same level you learnt the continuous perfect — I've been waiting for an hour (B1 #4): a process that stretches up to today. If you move it into the past, you get the fourth tense of a story — the Past Perfect Continuous. It answers the question: what had the person been busy with before the moment the story is about, and how long had it lasted?
The form: had been + the verb with -ing. had is the same for all persons, and after a pronoun it shortens to 'd.
| positive | She had been working since six. → She'd been working… |
| negative | I hadn't been sleeping well for weeks. |
| question | Had you been waiting long? / How long had they been living there? |
| short answer | Yes, I had. / No, she hadn't. |
This is the same structure as in B1 #4, only with had instead of have or has. In a short answer been is not repeated, just as there.
When it is used. This tense always has a point in the past — the moment of the story, usually in the Past Simple nearby. The Past Perfect Continuous looks back from this point at a process.
The first case is how long the process had lasted by that moment. Usually for, since, How long are nearby: They had been waiting for an hour when the train finally arrived. — "they were already an hour into their wait when the train came". Many languages use a simple past tense here, often with a word like "already". English takes a separate form, because it measures the stretch of time up to the point of the story.
The second is the traces of a process, visible at that moment: The ground was wet — it had been raining. We do not see the rain, but we see the wet ground. In the same way: Her eyes were red. She had been crying.
The third is the reason for a state in the past: She was exhausted because she had been working since six. The process explains why the person was the way the story found them.
Compare with the Present Perfect Continuous. The only difference is the point you measure from:
| now | then |
|---|---|
| I've been working here for five years. | I'd been working there for five years when the company closed. |
| measured from today | measured from a moment in the past |
Compare with the simple Past Perfect. The division is the same as in B1 #4: the continuous form talks about the activity, the simple one about the result.
| process — Continuous | result — Simple |
|---|---|
| She had been reading all evening. | She had read three chapters. |
| what she was busy with | how much she had done |
| He had been painting the fence. | He had painted the fence. |
| paint on his hands; the work may not have been finished | the fence is ready |
A number of finished things (pages, chapters) closes the action, so with it only the simple form is used. A length of time (for an hour) does not get in the way: it goes with the continuous form.
Compare with the Past Continuous. When I arrived, she was cooking — a snapshot: at the moment I arrived she was standing at the cooker. When I arrived, she had been cooking for two hours — by the time I arrived she already had two hours at the cooker behind her. The Past Continuous shows what was going on at that minute; the Past Perfect Continuous shows how long it had been going on before it and what was left afterwards.
State verbs — know, be, want, believe, have in the meaning "own" — have no continuous form here either (B1 #4). Instead, the simple Past Perfect is used: We had known each other for years. She had had the same car since university.
Four tenses — four roles. Here is the whole system of a story:
| tense | role | example |
|---|---|---|
| Past Simple | the chain of events | I opened the door and went in. |
| Past Continuous | the background at that minute | The radio was playing quietly. |
| Past Perfect | the backstory: what had happened before | Somebody had left the window open. |
| Past Perfect Continuous | a long backstory: what had been going on before | It had been raining all night. |
The rule of measure from B1 #2 works here too. A long backstory is used once or twice, to take a step back, and then the story returns to the Past Simple.
Don't say this. ✗ Had you been waited long? → ✓ Had you been waiting long? After been in this tense, only the -ing form is possible.
Check yourself. You and a friend started waiting for the bus at ten past eight, and it finally came at ten to nine: how do you tell this, looking back from the moment the bus came? Which form do you need in By midnight she ___ (write) ten pages — had written or had been writing? Why do people say He was out of breath because he had been running, and not because he was running?
show the answers
Common learner errors
written for your languagehas been inside a story about the past
✗ When I met her, she has been living in Paris for two years
✓ she had been living in Paris for two years
Learners have just mastered has been living and take it into a past story. But has ties the stretch of time to today, and here it is measured from the meeting, so you need had.
A simple past tense for the time up to a point
French ils attendaient depuis une heure, Spanish esperaban desde hacía una hora and German sie warteten seit einer Stunde use an ordinary past tense, and learners say When I arrived, they waited for an hour or they were waiting for an hour. In English this does not say that the wait had already lasted an hour; the first even means that they started waiting after I came. For "already an hour" you need ✓ When I arrived, they had been waiting for an hour.
since before a length of time
✗ She had been living there since two years
✓ She had been living there for two years
French depuis, German seit and Spanish desde go before both a starting point and a length of time. In English since goes before the starting point (since six), for before the length (B1 #4).
The continuous form with a number
✗ She had been reading three chapters
✓ She had read three chapters
Learners want to say "was reading" and "how much" at once. But a number is a finished result, and the continuous form does not talk about results.
A state verb with -ing
✗ I had been knowing him for years
✓ I had known him for years
In many languages "know" and "work" behave in the same way, so this rule has to be remembered on its own — as in B1 #4.
Pronunciation
4 minhad been in a positive sentence is unstressed: /həd bɪn/, after a pronoun — /d bɪn/. She'd been working sounds /ʃiːd bɪn ˈwɜːkɪŋ/. The group 'd been is said in one breath, been is a short /bɪn/, and the stress falls on the main verb.
In the negative and in a short answer had is full and stressed: I hadn't been sleeping well /aɪ ˈhædnt bɪn ˈsliːpɪŋ wel/, Yes, I had /jes aɪ ˈhæd/.
A long sentence is divided into groups of meaning (B1 #2). The pauses go between them, not inside them, and at the end of each group except the last the voice goes up a little — the listener understands that the story is going on:
She was exhausted ‖ because she'd been working since six ‖ and hadn't eaten anything.
Text
6 minWhen I got to the office at eight on Monday, the lights were already on and the door was open. For a moment I thought somebody had broken in. Then I saw Anna. She was sitting at her desk with her head in her hands, and the printer next to her was flashing — it had run out of paper.
Anna had clearly been working all night. There were three empty coffee cups on her desk, her eyes were red, and she was still wearing the jacket she had worn on Friday. It turned out that the client had phoned on Sunday afternoon and changed most of the numbers in our presentation. Anna had been rewriting it since then. By the time I came in, she had finished twenty slides and was checking the last few.
I made her a cup of tea and asked how long she had been sitting there. "Since about six last night," she said. "I'd been meaning to call you, but I didn't want to ruin your weekend."
At nine the client arrived. He had been travelling since five in the morning and was in a terrible mood. But when Anna showed him the new slides, he went quiet. Then he smiled. "You've been busy," he said. Nobody told him that she hadn't slept at all.
Exercises
35 min1. Gap fill. Past Simple, Past Continuous, Past Perfect or Past Perfect Continuous? Put the verbs into the right form.
- The ground was wet — it (rain) all night
- When I (get) to the office, Anna (check) the numbers
- She was exhausted because she (work) since six
- By nine o'clock she (rewrite) twenty slides
- They (wait) for an hour when the train finally (arrive)
- I (not / recognise) him at first — he (grow) a beard
- His hands were black because he (repair) his bike
- We (know) each other for ten years when we finally (start) a business together
Show the answers
2. Multiple choice. The simple Past Perfect or the continuous one?
- She (read) all evening, so her eyes were tired
- By midnight she (read) three chapters
- He (paint) the fence — there was paint all over his shirt
- By lunchtime he (paint) the whole fence
- How many emails you (send) before the meeting started?
- How long you (wait) before the doctor saw you?
Show the answers
3. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.
- When I met her, she has been living in Paris for two years.
- She had been reading three chapters before dinner.
- I had been knowing him since school.
- Had you been waited long when the doctor came?
- He was tired because he has been driving all day.
- It had been rain all night, so the roads were flooded.
Show the answers
4. Expand the prompt into an answer: explain where the traces came from. You need because and the Past Perfect Continuous.
- Why was she out of breath? (she / run)
- Why were his hands black? (he / repair / the car)
- Why were the children dirty? (they / play / in the garden)
- Why was the kitchen full of smoke? (somebody / cook / fish)
- Why were your eyes red? (I / cry)
Show the answers
5. Turn into a question with How long. Ask about the length of time.
- She had been working there for ten years when the factory closed.
- They had been waiting since nine.
- He had been learning Spanish for two years before he moved to Madrid.
- We had been driving for six hours when the car broke down. (ask with you)
- It had been raining for three days.
Show the answers
6. Rewrite in the past. The point of the story moves into the past: I'm tired → I was tired, the Present Perfect Continuous → the Past Perfect Continuous.
- I'm tired because I've been working all day.
- She's angry because she's been waiting for an hour.
- The streets are wet — it's been raining.
- He knows the city well because he's been living here for years.
- We're hungry because we haven't eaten since breakfast.
Show the answers
7. Say it in English.
Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence, with the forms of this lesson. 1) My friends started waiting at six. I arrived at half past six, and they were still waiting. Say this from the moment I arrived. 2) In the morning the ground was wet. The reason: rain all night. Say both things in one sentence. 3) She was tired. The reason: work in the garden from the morning up to that moment. 4) You and a friend are talking about the time before he moved to London. Ask him about the length of his English studies before the move. 5) We met twenty years before the moment in the story, and we were still friends then. Say how long we knew each other up to that moment.
Show the answers
Summary
Covered
- the Past Perfect Continuous in all its forms
- three cases of use
- the difference from the Present Perfect Continuous
- the simple Past Perfect and the Past Continuous
- state verbs
- four past tenses in one story and the measure of the backstory
Next — lesson 2: plans that fell through.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Vocabulary for your deck
16 words- turn out /ˌtɜːn ˈaʊt/ to become known in the end (it turned out that…)
- break in /ˌbreɪk ˈɪn/ to get into a building by force
- flash /flæʃ/ to go on and off (about a light)
- run out of /ˌrʌn ˈaʊt əv/ to have no more of something left (about a supply)
- clearly /ˈklɪəli/ obviously, in a way that is easy to see
- empty /ˈempti/ with nothing or nobody inside
- slide /slaɪd/ one page of a presentation shown on a screen
- printer /ˈprɪntə/ a machine that puts text and pictures from a computer onto paper
- rewrite /ˌriːˈraɪt/ to write again in a different way
- exhausted /ɪɡˈzɔːstɪd/ very tired
- ruin /ˈruːɪn/ to spoil something completely
- mood /muːd/ the way you feel at a particular time
- go quiet /ˌɡəʊ ˈkwaɪət/ to stop talking, to become silent
- chapter /ˈtʃæptə/ one of the parts of a book
- ground /ɡraʊnd/ the surface of the earth that you walk on
- flooded /ˈflʌdɪd/ covered with water
Writing
Eight to ten sentences — a story about a day when you found an unexpected scene. You need all four past tenses, and the long backstory at least twice.
Example
When I got home last Friday, the front door was open and music was playing upstairs. I was sure I had locked the door that morning. Then I found my brother in the kitchen. He had been staying with friends in Bristol, but their flat had flooded, so he had taken the first train to my place. He had been travelling since six and looked exhausted. I had given him a key years before and had completely forgotten about it. We ordered a pizza and talked until midnight.
Checklist
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional