Grammar ~63 min of the core left

Describe precisely: technology and law

After this lesson you can

I can build a precise definition with a relative clause and refer to the whole of the previous sentence.

Start the lesson Core 63 min · steps: 6 · optional: +2

Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.

Grammar

18 min

You built relative clauses with who, which, that, whose, where in B1 #17. In B2 #6 whom joined them: after a preposition (the man to whom I spoke) and after a word of quantity (both of whom). Today — the same for things, and one new use of which. This is the language of precise texts: instructions, contracts, rules, technical descriptions. In them you can't write "well, the one we talked about". Every definition is built so that it can't be understood in two ways, and every reference must point to exactly one thing.

A preposition before which — the formal variant. In conversation the preposition stands at the end of the clause (B1 #17). In a formal text it is moved forward, in front of the relative word:

ordinary speech formal text
the company (that) we work for the company for which we work
the conditions it depends on the conditions on which it depends
the date (that) the work must be finished by the date by which the work must be finished
the person (who) you should write to the person to whom you should write

Right after a preposition only which (about things) or whom (about people) is possible. that after a preposition is impossible, and the relative word can't be left out either: not the company for that we work and not the conditions on it depends.

With some prepositions there is simply no moving to the end, and the variant with which in front is the only one: the period during which the system was tested, the conditions under which data may be shared, the extent to which prices have risen ("how much prices have risen"). The opposite also happens. If the preposition is part of a phrasal verb (look after, put up with), it stays with the verb: the children we look after.

A word of quantity + of which. Just as people get both of whom (B2 #6), things get of which. Before of which comes a word of quantity: some, many, most, all, none, both, half, each, a number, the first, the last.

We received forty applications, twelve of which were incomplete. twelve of them
The firm has two offices, both of which are in Leeds. both of them
He gave three reasons, none of which convinced me. not one of them

Such a clause is always non-defining, with a comma. Two ideas — the total and the part — merge into one sentence. In reports this is the most compact form.

A noun + of which — "whose", about things. This is the formal twin of whose: the agreement, the terms of which were sent last week = the agreement, whose terms were sent last week ("the agreement; its terms were sent…"). Both variants are correct; whose about things (B1 #17) is usual in speech, while in documents of which is more common. The order: first the noun, then of which: the main purpose of which.

which about a whole sentence. Usually which replaces one noun. But at the end of a sentence, after a comma, it can replace everything that has been said — a whole fact:

He arrived two hours late, which annoyed everyone. and this annoyed everyone
The payment was delayed, which we had not expected. and we had not expected this
The lift is broken, which means that we'll have to use the stairs. so
The train was cancelled, which is why we were late. and that's the reason

Only which is possible here: that, what and it can't take this place. The comma before it is required. The most common continuations are which means (that)… and which is why….

Compare: the same beginning, but which points to different things.

He lent me his car, which was very old. which = the car
He lent me his car, which was very kind of him. which = the fact that he lent it

The test: if you can put "and this" in place of which, then which points to the whole fact.

Don't say this. ✗ the children after whom we look → ✓ the children (who) we look after. look after is one verb made of two words, and its particle is not torn away from the verb. ✗ We received forty applications, twelve of them were incomplete → ✓ twelve of which were incomplete: with them you get two sentences glued together with a comma. Either which or a full stop: We received forty applications. Twelve of them were incomplete.

The preposition — once. If the preposition has moved in front of which or whom, it is no longer at the end: ✗ the conditions on which the deal depends on → ✓ the conditions on which the deal depends.

Check yourself. Rewrite formally: the hotel we stayed at. How do you finish: I sent three emails, none of ___ were answered? What does which point to in She didn't call, which surprised me?

show the answers
the hotel at which we stayed; none of which; to the whole fact — that she didn't call.
Advertisement

Common learner errors

written for your language
1

that after a preposition

✗ the company for that we work

✓ the company for which we work

or the company (that) we work for. that is often learnt as the all-purpose relative word, for people and things alike. But right after a preposition only which or whom is possible; that works only if the preposition has gone to the end.

2

what instead of which about a whole sentence

✗ He was late, what annoyed everyone

✓ He was late, which annoyed everyone

German was, Dutch wat, French ce qui, Spanish and Portuguese lo que / o que look like "what", and learners translate them that way. But what means "the thing that" and stands where there is nothing before it to refer to: I don't know what he wants. A reference to what has been said is made with which.

3

of them after a comma

✗ We received forty applications, twelve of them were incomplete

✓ twelve of which were incomplete

or two sentences: We received forty applications. Twelve of them were incomplete. Many languages allow a comma between two full sentences, but English doesn't — the same mistake as with both of them in B2 #6.

4

The preposition twice

✗ the conditions on which the deal depends on

✓ the conditions on which the deal depends

The habit from B1 #17 puts the preposition at the end, the new rule puts it in front, and the hand writes both. There is one preposition in the clause: either before which or at the end.

Pronunciation

4 min

A long noun phrase sounds like one piece, and the pause comes after it, before the verb:

The conditions on which the agreement depends ‖ are listed on page four.

A pause inside the phrase (after conditions) breaks the link between the subject and the verb — a common mistake when a formal text is read aloud.

which about a whole sentence is separated by a pause, and the voice falls on it, as in an aside:

He arrived two hours late ‖ which annoyed everyone.

Weak forms: of which — /əv wɪtʃ/, to whom — /tə huːm/. which sounds the same as witch: /wɪtʃ/, with no /h/.

Advertisement

Text

6 min

The new access system, the main purpose of which is to keep the building secure, comes into force on 1 June. It replaces the old paper passes, many of which had been lost or copied over the years.

Under the new system, every employee receives a personal card, without which the main doors will not open. The card is linked to a database in which all times of entry and exit are recorded. This information is kept for thirty days, after which it is deleted automatically. Visitors must be registered in advance by the person with whom they have a meeting.

The system was tested last month in two offices, both of which reported problems with the side doors. These have now been fixed, which means that the doors on Mill Street can be used again.

The company has also signed an agreement with a security firm, the terms of which are available on the staff website. It sets out the conditions under which recordings may be shared with the police. Staff whose cards are lost or stolen must report this within 24 hours. There is also a scheme under which a temporary card can be issued at reception, which should reduce queues in the morning.

Questions about the system should be sent to the facilities manager, to whom all requests for changes should also be addressed.

Exercises

35 min

1. Rewrite formally: put the preposition before which or whom.

  1. The company we work for has offices in five countries.
  2. This is the problem I wrote to you about.
  3. The conditions the loan depends on are listed below.
  4. The person you should send the form to is Ms Hale.
  5. The date the work must be finished by is 30 June.
  6. The hotel we stayed at was excellent.
Show the answers
The company for which we work has offices in five countries; This is the problem about which I wrote to you; The conditions on which the loan depends are listed below; The person to whom you should send the form is Ms Hale; The date by which the work must be finished is 30 June; The hotel at which we stayed was excellent

2. Join two sentences with which about the whole sentence.

  1. He arrived two hours late. + This annoyed everyone.
  2. The payment was delayed. + We had not expected this.
  3. The lift is broken. + This means that we'll have to use the stairs.
  4. She didn't reply to my email. + This surprised me.
  5. The train was cancelled. + That is why we were late.
  6. The company has cut its prices. + This should attract new customers.
Show the answers
He arrived two hours late, which annoyed everyone; The payment was delayed, which we had not expected / The payment was delayed, which we hadn't expected; The lift is broken, which means that we'll have to use the stairs / The lift is broken, which means we'll have to use the stairs; She didn't reply to my email, which surprised me; The train was cancelled, which is why we were late; The company has cut its prices, which should attract new customers

3. Join two sentences with of which or of whom.

  1. We received forty applications. + Twelve of them were incomplete.
  2. The firm has two offices. + Both of them are in Leeds.
  3. He gave three reasons. + None of them convinced me.
  4. Sixty people came to the meeting. + Most of them were local residents.
  5. The contract has twenty pages. + The first five of them deal with payment.
  6. The agreement comes into force in May. + Its terms were sent last week.
Show the answers
We received forty applications, twelve of which were incomplete; The firm has two offices, both of which are in Leeds; He gave three reasons, none of which convinced me; Sixty people came to the meeting, most of whom were local residents; The contract has twenty pages, the first five of which deal with payment; The agreement, the terms of which were sent last week, comes into force in May / The agreement, whose terms were sent last week, comes into force in May

4. Put in which, whom, whose or what.

  1. The person to you spoke is our director
  2. She forgot my birthday, really hurt
  3. We have three printers, two of are broken
  4. The system on we depend is fifteen years old
  5. A customer card had been stolen called the bank
  6. I don't understand he wants
  7. The applicants, most of were students, waited outside
  8. The flight was cancelled, meant that we had to stay another night
Show the answers
whom; which; which; which; whose; what; whom; which

5. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.

  1. The company for that we work is based in Leeds.
  2. He forgot the tickets, what made her angry.
  3. We sent forty letters, ten of them were returned.
  4. The conditions on which the deal depends on are listed below.
  5. These are the children after whom we look.
  6. The report, the main purpose of it is to compare costs, is ready.
Show the answers
The company for which we work is based in Leeds / The company we work for is based in Leeds / The company that we work for is based in Leeds; He forgot the tickets, which made her angry; We sent forty letters, ten of which were returned / We sent forty letters. Ten of them were returned; The conditions on which the deal depends are listed below / The conditions the deal depends on are listed below; These are the children we look after / These are the children who we look after / These are the children that we look after; The report, the main purpose of which is to compare costs, is ready / The report, whose main purpose is to compare costs, is ready

6. Say it in English.

Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence, with the forms of this lesson. 1) We received thirty complaints. Most of them were about prices. 2) He didn't answer the letter. This surprised me. 3) We are ready to sign the contract on certain conditions. Point to them and say that these are the conditions. 4) You wrote to a person. That person has already left the company. (formal) 5) We have two warehouses. Both are outside the town. (one sentence)

Show the answers
We received thirty complaints, most of which were about prices / We received thirty complaints, most of which concerned prices; He didn't answer the letter, which surprised me / He didn't reply to the letter, which surprised me; These are the conditions on which we are ready to sign the contract / These are the terms on which we are prepared to sign the contract / These are the conditions under which we are ready to sign the contract / These are the conditions on which we are prepared to sign the contract / These are the terms on which we are ready to sign the contract; The person to whom you wrote has already left the company; We have two warehouses, both of which are outside the town / We have two warehouses, both of which are out of town
Advertisement

Summary

Covered: a preposition before which and whom in formal texts and why that is impossible after a preposition; prepositions that don't move to the end (during which, under which, the extent to which), and phrasal verbs, whose preposition stays with the verb; of which after a word of quantity and after a noun (the terms of which); which about a whole sentence, which means that, which is why. Next — lesson 15: saying it concisely.

End of the core

The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.

Lesson 123

optional

Vocabulary for your deck

14 words
  • terms /tɜːmz/ the conditions of an agreement or a contract
  • come into force /ˌkʌm ˌɪntə ˈfɔːs/ (about a law or a rule) to start to apply
  • purpose /ˈpɜːpəs/ what something is for; its aim
  • secure /sɪˈkjʊə/ protected against danger, crime or attack
  • access /ˈækses/ the right or the possibility to enter a place or use something
  • database /ˈdeɪtəbeɪs/ a large collection of information stored on a computer
  • entry /ˈentri/ going into a place
  • delete /dɪˈliːt/ to remove information, especially from a computer
  • register /ˈredʒɪstə/ to put a name on an official list
  • temporary /ˈtemprəri/ lasting only for a limited time
  • recording /rɪˈkɔːdɪŋ/ sound or pictures that have been recorded (video, audio)
  • applicant /ˈæplɪkənt/ a person who formally asks for a job, a place or a document
  • extent /ɪkˈstent/ how great or how far something is; degree
  • scheme /skiːm/ an official plan or programme

Writing

Eight to ten sentences — a description of rules or a system: passes for a building, a car park, a gym membership. You need a preposition before which or whom, one of which and one which about a whole sentence.

Example

The car park, the main purpose of which is to serve hotel guests, is open from 6 am to midnight. Every guest receives a parking card, without which the barrier will not open. There are eighty spaces, ten of which are reserved for disabled drivers. Cars may stay for up to seven days, after which a daily fee is charged. The conditions under which a car may be removed are set out on the sign at the entrance. Guests whose cards are lost should contact reception, which is open all night. Payment can be made online, which means that you don't need to queue at the desk. Complaints should be sent to the manager, to whom all requests should be addressed.

Checklist

The draft is saved on this device

Got a feature idea?

Send idea
Advertisement
Advertisement