Say it concisely
I can replace a clause with a participle phrase and make a text half as long without losing the meaning.
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Grammar
18 minA good English text says a lot in few words. One of the main ways to compress it is a participle phrase. A clause with who or which (B1 #17) or with the conjunctions when, because, after shrinks to one form of the verb: The man who is standing there → The man standing there. Many languages do this with participles, and some have a whole set of them, with separate forms for "doing", "done" and "having done". English has fewer forms — three, and each of them works both next to a noun (the man standing there) and for the whole sentence (Standing there, I…).
The form: three forms, three meanings.
| form | meaning | example |
|---|---|---|
| -ing | the subject itself acts — at the same time as the main action or just before it | Opening the door, I saw a light. |
| the third form | the action is done to the subject, this is the passive | Built in 1890, the bridge is still in use. |
| having + the third form | the subject itself acts, and this was over before the main action | Having finished the report, he went home. |
The negative is not before the form: Not knowing the way, we took a taxi. Not having seen the report, I can't comment. There is also a passive of an earlier action: Having been warned, we left early ("because we had been warned"). It is enough to recognise it.
When it is used.
Instead of a defining clause with who or which. who or which is dropped from the clause together with be: the man (who is) standing there, the documents (which were) sent yesterday. The -ing form here also works for verbs that have no continuous tense: a box containing old letters = a box which contains old letters, people living near the airport = people who live near the airport. Such a reduced clause is quite normal in conversation too.
The commas are the same as in a full clause (B1 #17). If the phrase answers the question "which one exactly?", there are no commas: The documents sent yesterday are on your desk.
Instead of a clause of time and reason. A phrase at the start of the sentence replaces when, while, after, because, as:
| before | after |
|---|---|
| While I was waiting for the bus, I read the news. | Waiting for the bus, I read the news. |
| Because he felt ill, he stayed at home. | Feeling ill, he stayed at home. |
| After she had read the letter, she called her lawyer. | Having read the letter, she called her lawyer. |
| As it was written in a hurry, the report had many mistakes. | Written in a hurry, the report had many mistakes. |
You can also keep the conjunction — then the meaning is more precise: After finishing the report, he went home, While waiting, When asked about the delay, he said nothing ("when he was asked").
At the end: a result or a second action. The storm closed the road, forcing drivers to make a detour — "so drivers had to make a detour". She left the room, slamming the door — "and she slammed the door as she went".
The main condition: the subject is shared. A participle phrase has no subject of its own, and it takes the subject of the main part. ✗ Walking down the street, the building looked old means that the building was walking down the street. You need ✓ Walking down the street, I noticed that the building looked old. If the subjects are different, keep the full clause: When I opened the door, the dog ran out.
Compare -ing and having:
| Walking home, I met Tom. | met him on the way — at the same time |
| Having walked home, I had a shower. | first got home, then the shower |
And -ing with the third form:
| the people interviewing the candidates | those who are doing the interviews |
| the people interviewed for the job | those who were interviewed |
Where it is heard. Phrases at the start of a sentence are a feature of written language: a report, a news story, a story. In conversation people usually say When I got home, I…. A reduced clause (the man standing there) is normal everywhere.
More examples:
| Anyone wishing to speak should raise their hand. | anyone who wants to speak… |
| Asked about the delay, the spokesperson said nothing. | when the spokesperson was asked about the delay… |
| Not having a car, we rely on buses. | because we don't have a car… |
Don't say this. ✗ The man stealing the car was arrested meaning "the man who stole it" → ✓ The man who stole the car was arrested. The -ing form in a defining phrase means "who does it or was doing it at that moment", and it doesn't express a single finished action in the past.
No being. For a finished passive — just the third form: ✗ Being built in 1890, the bridge is still in use → ✓ Built in 1890, the bridge is still in use. being built means "which is being built now": the bridge being built near the station.
Check yourself. Make it shorter: The woman who is sitting by the window is my aunt. Which form is needed: ___ (write) in 1850, the novel is still popular? What is wrong with Having read the letter, the answer was clear?
show the answers
Common learner errors
written for your languageA dangling phrase
✗ Having read the report, the numbers seemed wrong
✓ Having read the report, I thought the numbers were wrong
In some languages such a sentence only sounds careless, and in speech it often passes unnoticed. In English it is a real mistake, and the reader sees a funny picture: numbers that read the report.
-ing instead of the third form
✗ the documents sending yesterday
✓ the documents sent yesterday
The third form of most verbs looks exactly like the past tense (sent, damaged), so it is not recognised as a participle, and the -ing form starts to seem like a participle for every case. The test: the subject does it itself — -ing; something is done to it — the third form.
An extra being
✗ Being built in 1890, the bridge is still in use
✓ Built in 1890, the bridge is still in use
A learner building the passive step by step adds being, as if the passive needed it. But being built means "which is being built now": the bridge being built near the station. For a finished passive — just the third form.
Commas around every phrase
Some languages (Russian and Ukrainian, for example) always set off a participle phrase after a noun with commas. In English commas change the meaning: The documents, sent yesterday, are on your desk means that the documents are already known, and we just add when they were sent. If you mean "the documents that were sent yesterday", there are no commas: The documents sent yesterday are on your desk.
Pronunciation
4 minA phrase at the start is separated from the main part by a pause, and there are no pauses inside it:
Having finished the report ‖ he went home. Built in 1890 and rebuilt twice since then ‖ the bridge carries four thousand cars a day.
A reduced clause sounds together with its noun, without pauses:
The man standing by the door is my brother.
having is unstressed and quick, and the participle sounds stronger: having finished — /hævɪŋ ˈfɪnɪʃt/. Pronounce the third forms to the end: examined /ɪɡˈzæmɪnd/ — with /d/, with no extra vowel; built /bɪlt/, worried /ˈwʌrid/.
Text
6 minBuilt in 1890 and rebuilt twice since then, the old bridge over the River Wey carries around four thousand cars a day. Having examined the structure last spring, the council's engineers found serious cracks in two of the supports. Their report, sent to the council in March, recommended closing one lane immediately.
Worried about the cost of repairs, the council has not yet discussed the report. Residents living near the bridge say that lorries weighing more than ten tonnes still use it every day, ignoring the signs placed at both ends. "Standing on the pavement, you can feel the whole bridge shake," says Ann Morris, whose house is fifty metres from the river.
A group calling itself Save Our Bridge has now written to the mayor. Asked about the delay, a council spokesperson said that a decision would be taken by the end of the summer. Not having seen the full report, local businesses fear that the bridge could be closed completely, forcing drivers to make a twenty-minute detour through the town centre.
Having studied similar cases in other towns, experts believe that a full repair would take at least a year. Until then, the bridge, used by thousands of people every day, remains open — and nobody seems to know for how long.
Exercises
35 min1. Gap fill. Put the verb into the right form: -ing, the third form or having + the third form.
- The man (stand) by the door is my brother
- The letters (send) yesterday arrived this morning
- (finish) the report, she went home early
- (build) in 1890, the bridge needs repairs
- Anyone (wish) to speak should raise their hand
- (not / know) the way, we asked a police officer
- Cars (park) outside the school will be removed
- (lose) his keys twice, he now keeps a spare set at work
Show the answers
2. Rewrite, replacing the clause with who or which with a participle phrase.
- The woman who is sitting by the window is my aunt.
- The documents which were sent yesterday are on your desk.
- People who live near the airport complain about the noise.
- I found a box which contained old letters.
- The houses which were damaged in the storm will be rebuilt.
- Students who want to join the trip should register by Friday.
Show the answers
3. Rewrite, replacing the clause with a conjunction with a participle phrase.
- After she had read the letter, she called her lawyer.
- Because he felt tired, he went to bed early.
- While I was waiting for the bus, I read the news.
- When he was asked about the money, he said nothing.
- Because we didn't know the address, we called the hotel.
- As the report was written in a hurry, it contained many mistakes.
Show the answers
4. Find the dangling phrase and correct it. Start with the words in brackets. In items 1–2 the phrase stays, and the main part gets a subject that does the action of the phrase; in items 3–5 the phrase is expanded into a clause.
- Walking down the street, the building looked old. (Walking down the street, I noticed…)
- Having read the report, the numbers seemed wrong. (Having read the report, I thought…)
- Opening the door, the dog ran out. (When I…)
- Having finished dinner, the waiter brought the bill. (After we…)
- Waiting for the train, it started to rain. (While we…)
Show the answers
5. Compress two sentences into one with a participle phrase.
- The bridge was built in 1890. + It carries four thousand cars a day.
- The engineers examined the structure. + Then they recommended closing one lane.
- The report was sent in March. + It has not been discussed yet.
- The residents are worried about the delay. + They have written to the mayor.
- The storm closed the main road. + It forced drivers to take a long detour.
Show the answers
6. Say it in English.
Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence, with a participle phrase. 1) A girl is sitting by the window. She is my sister. 2) He finished work. After that he went home. 3) We didn't know the address, so we called the hotel. 4) Some letters went out on Monday. Those letters haven't arrived yet. 5) The house was built a hundred years ago. It is still in good condition.
Show the answers
Summary
Covered: the three forms of a participle phrase — -ing, the third form, having + the third form — and their meanings; the negative Not knowing; the reduced relative clause, including state verbs (containing, living), and its commas; a phrase instead of a clause of time and reason, with a conjunction and without; -ing at the end of a sentence; the shared subject and the dangling phrase; the extra being. Next — lesson 16: emphasising the main point.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Vocabulary for your deck
15 words- rebuild /ˌriːˈbɪld/ to build again after damage
- structure /ˈstrʌktʃə/ something that has been built, such as a bridge
- lane /leɪn/ a part of a road for one line of traffic
- council /ˈkaʊnsl/ the group of people elected to run a town or city
- resident /ˈrezɪdənt/ a person who lives in a particular place
- lorry /ˈlɒri/ a large vehicle for carrying goods by road
- tonne /tʌn/ a thousand kilograms
- pavement /ˈpeɪvmənt/ the path for people on foot at the side of a street
- mayor /meə/ the head of a town or city council
- spokesperson /ˈspəʊkspɜːsn/ a person who speaks to the press for an organisation
- detour /ˈdiːtʊə/ a longer way round, used when a road is closed
- ignore /ɪɡˈnɔː/ to pay no attention to something or somebody
- remain /rɪˈmeɪn/ to stay; to continue to be
- contain /kənˈteɪn/ to have something inside
- slam /slæm/ to shut a door hard and noisily
Writing
Eight to ten sentences — a short piece about a building, a road or a park in your town. You need three phrases of different kinds (-ing, the third form, having) and one reduced relative clause.
Example
Opened in 1905, the town library is one of the oldest buildings in the centre. Having survived two fires and a flood, it was finally renovated last year. The work, paid for by local businesses, took eight months. People visiting the library today will find a café on the ground floor and a garden behind the building. Not wanting to lose the old atmosphere, the architects kept the original wooden shelves. The reading room, used by students during exams, is now open until ten. Asked about the cost, the director said that it was "money well spent".
Checklist
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional