Give a balanced view
I can present both sides of a question without taking either side.
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Grammar
18 minIn B1 #32 you learnt to say "although": although, even though, despite, however. In B2 #23 the essay links whereas, on the other hand, nevertheless and their punctuation came in. Today these words come together into a system. To show both sides of a question, you need to tell apart two different relations between facts. They are easy to mix up, but in English each of them has its own conjunctions.
Contrast — two facts stand side by side, both are true, and one does not get in the way of the other. We simply compare: one thing is like this, the other is different: Rent has risen, whereas wages have not. Concession — one fact should have stopped the other, but it did not: Although it was expensive, we bought it.
The test is simple. If after the conjunction you can add "still" or "even so", it is a concession. If the two parts can change places and the meaning stays the same, it is contrast: "wages have not risen, but rent has" says the same thing.
Form: what comes after the word decides.
| what follows | contrast | concession |
|---|---|---|
| a clause with a verb | whereas, while | although, even though, while, much as |
| a noun or -ing | unlike | despite, in spite of |
| a clause after a preposition | — | despite the fact that, in spite of the fact that |
| an adjective or adverb without a verb | — | albeit |
| a new sentence | In contrast, On the other hand, | However, Nevertheless, Nonetheless, |
Contrast in one sentence — whereas and while. whereas sounds formal and lives in writing; while is neutral and fits everywhere. Before whereas in the middle of a sentence there is a comma. The two parts are usually built in the same way, so that the comparison is seen at once: The old model was heavy, whereas the new one weighs under a kilo.
Contrast between sentences. In contrast, starts a new sentence and sets it against the one before. Before a noun, contrast is expressed with unlike: Unlike large firms, small companies cannot move staff between teams. The pair on the one hand … on the other hand puts the question on two sides of the scales. The first half is used only if the second one follows. The second can also stand alone, as in B2 #23.
A new concession: much as — "however much I…", "although I really…". The speaker admits a feeling and still does the opposite. That is why much as goes only before verbs of attitude: like, love, admire, respect, understand, sympathise with, want, dislike, hate. The word order is normal: Much as I like the idea, it won't work.
despite the fact that. You know from B1 #32 that despite is not followed by a whole clause. The bridge to a clause is the words the fact that: Despite the fact that the office was closed, customers noticed little difference. This is heavy and suits writing. In speech although is simpler.
albeit — a formal "though". It goes inside a phrase and is followed by an adjective, an adverb or a short phrase, but not by a clause with a verb: a small, albeit important, change, They agreed, albeit reluctantly.
Linking words of concession between sentences. nonetheless means the same as nevertheless from B2 #23, "even so". Its commas are the same as with however: at the start of a sentence there is a comma after it, and inside a sentence it has commas on both sides: It is, nonetheless, the best plan we have.
while works both ways, and this is a trap. While Anna loves big cities, her brother prefers the countryside — contrast: she is like this, he is different. While I agree with the principle, I disagree with the method — concession: "although I agree with the principle". Only the meaning tells them apart. If while can be replaced with although, it is a concession. while also has a third meaning, about time: "during the time that", but the situation shows it.
Compare.
| Although the flat is small, it is very bright. | Concession: a small flat is often dark, but this one is bright. |
| The flat is small, whereas the garden is huge. | Contrast: two different things side by side, one does not get in the way of the other. |
Concession is "against what you expect", contrast is "and the other one is different". Native speakers sometimes write although where there is a simple comparison too. This is not a mistake, but whereas and while show more clearly that you are only comparing.
How to keep the balance. A balanced text gives every opinion to its owner and does not say "I think". The verbs from B2 #13 and B2 #23 will help: argue, point out.
| There are reasonable arguments on both sides. | Both sides have good points. |
| Supporters argue that… Critics, on the other hand, point out that… | People who are for it say… People who are against it say… |
| It is true that… Nonetheless, … | Yes, this is so… But even so… |
| Whether … depends largely on… | The answer is mostly decided by… |
More examples:
| Tom drives to work, while his wife cycles. | Tom goes by car, and his wife goes by bike. |
| Much as I respect her experience, I can't agree with her. | I respect her experience very much, but I still can't agree. |
| The report was useful, albeit a little long. | useful, though a little long |
| Unlike his brother, Mark hates flying. | His brother doesn't mind flying, but Mark hates it. |
| The plan has weaknesses. Nonetheless, it is the best we have. | Even so, it is the best we have. |
| Despite the fact that the evidence is limited, the trend is clear. | There is not much evidence, but the trend is clear. |
Don't say this. ✗ Much as the weather was bad, we went out → ✓ Although the weather was bad, we went out. Bad weather is not our feeling, and much as does not fit here. ✗ Although the plan is risky, however, it is our only option → ✓ Although the plan is risky, it is our only option: one link takes one conjunction.
Check yourself. Which word do you need in My sister reads a lot, ___ I hardly ever open a book — one of contrast or one of concession? How do you finish Despite ___ it was late, we stayed? What is wrong with The idea is good, albeit it is expensive?
show the answers
Common learner errors
written for your languagealthough before a noun
✗ Although the bad weather, the match went ahead
✓ Despite the bad weather, the match went ahead
or Although the weather was bad, …. In some languages one word does both jobs: Japanese ni mo kakawarazu follows a noun and a whole clause alike. In English the line is strict: although takes only a clause with a verb, despite only a noun or -ing. This is the mirror of despite it was raining from B1 #32.
whereas meaning "although"
✗ Whereas it was raining, we went for a walk
✓ Although it was raining, we went for a walk
French alors que compares two facts, but it can also mean "although" (alors qu'il pouvait aider, il est parti), and both meanings go into whereas. But whereas has only one meaning — comparison.
despite that before a clause
✗ Despite that the price was high, the tickets sold out
✓ Despite the fact that the price was high…
or Although the price was high…. Spanish a pesar de que, Portuguese apesar de que and French malgré que are translated piece by piece: "despite" — despite, "that" — that. The words the fact are missing, and without them despite cannot take a clause.
albeit before a clause
✗ The solution works, albeit it is slow
✓ The solution works, albeit slowly
or …, although it is slow. albeit is learnt as one more word for "although", and so it gets a whole clause after it, as although does. But albeit takes only a word or a short phrase.
Two conjunctions for one link
✗ Although the plan is risky, however, it is our only option
✓ Although the plan is risky, it is our only option
or The plan is risky. However, it is our only option. Chinese suīrán … dànshì and Vietnamese mặc dù … nhưng use a pair of words, and both are carried over. This is the same rule as although … but in B1 #32: one concession, one word.
contrary to instead of unlike
✗ Contrary to his brother, Mark hates flying
✓ Unlike his brother, Mark hates flying
French contrairement à and Italian contrariamente a lead to contrary to. To compare two people or things, English says unlike.
Pronunciation
4 minIn contrast both parts being compared are stressed, and the voice seems to put them on the scales:
Rent has risen, ‖ whereas wages have not.
If you stress only one of them, the comparison disappears, and the sentence sounds like a simple statement.
The pair on the one hand … on the other hand — two different tones. On the first half the voice rises towards the end: the thought is not finished, wait for more. On the second it falls:
On the one hand, ↗ it's cheaper; ‖ on the other hand, ↘ it takes twice as long.
The concession ends with a rise, the main part with a fall. The pause between them is a must:
Much as I like the idea, ↗ ‖ it won't work. ↘
Words of the lesson: whereas /weərˈæz/ — the stress is on the second syllable, and the /r/ is pronounced because a vowel follows; albeit /ɔːlˈbiːɪt/ — three syllables, the middle one stressed; nonetheless /ˌnʌnðəˈles/ — the main stress is on the last syllable.
Text
6 minA FOUR-DAY WEEK: BOTH SIDES OF THE ARGUMENT
Should companies move to a four-day working week? The question divides managers and employees alike, and there are reasonable arguments on both sides.
On the one hand, supporters point out that people who work four days are often just as productive as before. In several trials, staff took fewer sick days, while managers reported no fall in output. Even though the office was closed one day a week, most customers noticed little difference. Much as some sceptics dislike such small studies, their results are difficult to ignore.
On the other hand, critics argue that the idea suits some businesses far better than others. A design studio can fit its work into four days, whereas a hospital cannot simply close on Fridays. Unlike large firms, small companies often have no one to cover for absent colleagues. Some employees also found that the extra day came at a price: their working days became longer and more intense. They were happier overall, albeit more tired by Thursday evening.
Despite the fact that the evidence is still limited, the trials have moved the debate forward. The four-day week is clearly not a solution for every workplace. Nonetheless, it deserves to be tested seriously, and whether its benefits outweigh its costs will depend largely on the kind of work involved.
Exercises
35 min1. Multiple choice: whereas or although? Decide whether it is contrast or concession.
- the tickets were expensive, the concert was sold out
- My sister loves big cities, I prefer small towns
- he had trained for months, he didn't finish the race
- The old model was heavy, the new one weighs under a kilo
- the hotel was cheap, it was very clean
- In the north the summers are cool, in the south they are hot and dry
Show the answers
2. Gap fill. much as, albeit, despite, despite the fact that, unlike, nonetheless, on the one hand. Use each one once.
- I admire his energy, I can't work with him
- The change was useful, small
- the rain, the match went ahead
- the train was late, we arrived on time
- the capital, the rest of the country is quiet in August
- The plan has some weaknesses. , it is the best we have
- , the new system is faster; on the other hand, it costs twice as much
Show the answers
3. Join the two sentences into one with the word in brackets. Write the whole sentence.
- Anna works from home. Her husband travels to the office every day. (whereas)
- I like the design. It is too expensive for us. (much as)
- The results were positive. They were small. (albeit)
- The flight was delayed. We reached the meeting on time. (despite the fact that)
- Large firms can move staff between teams. Small firms cannot. (unlike)
- The new road will reduce traffic. It will destroy part of the park. (on the one hand)
Show the answers
4. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.
- Although the long journey, the children were in good spirits.
- Whereas it was raining, we went for a walk.
- The solution works, albeit it is slow.
- Although the plan is risky, however, it is our only option.
- Despite that the price was high, the tickets sold out.
- Much as the hotel was cheap, it was very comfortable.
Show the answers
5. Rewrite with the word in brackets, without changing the meaning.
- Although the company made a profit, it closed two shops. (despite)
- Although I understand your concerns, I think we should go ahead. (much as)
- Prices rose sharply in the city. In the countryside they stayed the same. (while)
- The team was small, but it was very experienced. (although)
- He agreed to help, but he was reluctant. (albeit)
Show the answers
6. Say it in English.
Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it with the forms of this lesson. 1) Give both sides of the plan, first one and then the other: it is cheap; it will take two years. 2) Compare in one sentence, as on scales: my brother loves football; I prefer tennis. 3) I respect his experience very much. All the same, I don't agree with him. Start with your feeling. 4) The report was short. Even so, it contained everything we needed. Use the long, formal bridge to a clause. 5) The decision was right, but it came late. Say it in one short sentence with only one verb.
Show the answers
Summary
Covered: contrast and concession as two different relations; contrast — whereas, while, unlike, In contrast,, on the one hand … on the other hand; concession — much as with verbs of attitude, despite the fact that, albeit without a clause, nonetheless; while that works both ways; the formulas of a balanced text. Next — lesson 26: cause and effect.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Vocabulary for your deck
15 words- albeit /ɔːlˈbiːɪt/ although, though (formal)
- nonetheless /ˌnʌnðəˈles/ in spite of that; even so
- in contrast /ɪn ˈkɒntrɑːst/ showing that something is different from what was just said
- on the one hand /ɒn ðə ˈwʌn hænd/ used to give the first side of an argument
- much as /ˈmʌtʃ əz/ although (I) really (like, respect…)
- supporter /səˈpɔːtə/ a person who is for an idea, a plan or a team
- critic /ˈkrɪtɪk/ a person who says what is wrong with something
- sceptic /ˈskeptɪk/ a person who doubts that something is true or will work
- trial /ˈtraɪəl/ a test of something new for a period of time
- output /ˈaʊtpʊt/ the amount of work done or produced
- sick day /ˈsɪk deɪ/ a day off work because you are ill
- cover for /ˈkʌvə fə/ to do the work of a colleague who is away
- intense /ɪnˈtens/ very strong; very busy and tiring
- divide /dɪˈvaɪd/ to make people disagree (about opinions)
- debate /dɪˈbeɪt/ a discussion between people with different views
Writing
Eight to ten sentences — a balanced look at a question people disagree about: school uniform, a charge for driving into the town centre, a ban on phones in schools. Give the arguments of both sides without showing your own opinion. You need two contrasts, two concessions, one albeit and the pair on the one hand … on the other hand.
Example
Should mobile phones be banned in schools? The question divides parents and teachers alike. On the one hand, supporters argue that pupils concentrate better without phones, and several schools have reported calmer classrooms. Much as teenagers may dislike the rule, it seems to reduce bullying. On the other hand, critics point out that phones can be useful in lessons, whereas a ban teaches pupils nothing about using them sensibly. Unlike younger children, older pupils often need their phones to get home safely. Despite the fact that the early results are positive, the studies are small. The effect is real, albeit modest. Whether a ban works will depend largely on how it is enforced.
Checklist
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional