Compare two systems
I can compare two options so that the comparison reads as an argument, not as a list.
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Grammar
18 minYou can already compare single things: far cheaper, twice as fast as, the more…, the better (B1 #35). The linking words whereas, on the other hand and however came in B2 #23, and unlike and in contrast in B2 #25, where they set two sides of an argument against each other. Today the task is different: to compare two options in a report or a letter so that a conclusion grows out of the comparison. For this you need three things: the order of presentation, words that openly name a similarity or a difference, and an exact measure of the difference.
The order of presentation: block by block or point by point. Block by block — first everything about the first option, then everything about the second. Point by point — in turns: the price of one and of the other, the speed of one and of the other. For a short text point by point is better: the reader doesn't have to keep the first block in mind, and each difference immediately turns into an argument. A paragraph starts with the point (The two systems differ mainly in cost), not with the name of a system.
Words of comparison: three grammatical types. As with the linking words in B2 #23, the type decides what comes next.
| type | words | what follows | example |
|---|---|---|---|
| preposition | compared with (to), in comparison with, unlike, like, as opposed to | a noun | Unlike the old system, the new one works offline. |
| conjunction | whereas, while | a clause | The old system needs a server, whereas the new one runs online. |
| adverb | by contrast, in contrast, similarly, likewise, on the other hand | a new sentence, a comma | The first is cheap. By contrast, the second is expensive. |
unlike is a preposition meaning "different from" (B2 #25). Only a noun or a pronoun follows it, and the main idea comes later, in the main part: Unlike Tom, Anna drives. compared with and compared to are equally correct in British English. as opposed to means "and not, rather than": £45 a month, as opposed to £70. similarly and likewise mean "in the same way": they show that the second thing works like the first.
You compare like with like: a system with a system, a price with a price. Unlike the old system, the price of the new one is low is grammatical, strictly speaking, but it compares a system with a price. Better: Unlike the old system, the new one is cheap.
Similarity and difference. the same as — "identical to"; similar to — "almost the same as"; different from — "not the same as" (in British English people also say different to; different than is the American version). The verb is differ: The systems differ in price — the difference between them is the price; differ from — be different from. The noun: the main difference between A and B is that…
The measure of the difference. To the words from B1 #35 (much, far, slightly, twice as … as) add:
| meaning | example | |
|---|---|---|
| considerably, significantly | noticeably, by a lot | considerably cheaper |
| marginally | by a very small amount | marginally faster |
| no + comparative + than | not at all | no cheaper than the old one |
| just as … as | exactly as | just as reliable as |
| nowhere near as … as | not at all as, far from | nowhere near as fast as |
no better than means "just as bad": The new version is no better than the old one. nowhere near as is neutral to conversational; in a report people also write not nearly as.
the …, the … without a verb. In B1 #35 both parts were full: The longer we waited, the angrier he got. In a report the verb be is often left out, and you get a compact formula: The larger the team, the slower the decisions. The simpler the interface, the better.
"The first" and "the second". To avoid repeating the names, people say the former — the first of the two just named, and the latter — the second (B2 #27): We tested System A and System B. The former is older; the latter is cheaper. These are bookish words; in conversation people say the first one and the second one.
Examples:
| Compared with last year, sales are up by a fifth. | sales are 20% higher than last year |
| In comparison with the bus, the train is far more comfortable. | the train is much more comfortable than the bus |
| Unlike its rivals, the company has no debt. | its rivals have debts; the company doesn't |
| Rents in the centre rose sharply. By contrast, rents in the suburbs hardly changed. | in the suburbs the picture was different |
| The first school has a long waiting list. Similarly, the second is full. | the second school is in the same situation |
| My phone is exactly the same as yours. | our phones are identical |
| The new design is very similar to the old one. | the new design is almost the same as the old one |
| The plan is no cheaper than the current one. | the plan does not cost any less |
| The coach is nowhere near as fast as the train. | the train is much faster than the coach |
| We chose the cheaper option, as opposed to the faster one. | we chose the cheaper option and not the faster one |
Don't say this. ✗ Unlike the old system works offline, the new one does not → ✓ Unlike the old system, the new one does not work offline or The old system works offline, whereas the new one does not. After unlike — a noun, not a clause.
By contrast and on the contrary are different things. By contrast compares two things: System A is expensive. By contrast, System B is cheap. On the contrary rejects what has just been said: — Is it expensive? — On the contrary, it's very cheap. ✗ System A is expensive. On the contrary, System B is cheap → ✓ By contrast, System B is cheap.
The second term of a comparison. In a written comparison you name what you compare with: not just This option is more effective, but This option is more effective than the current one.
Check yourself. What comes after unlike, and what after whereas? The new bus is not faster than the old one, not even a little: how do you say "not faster" in three words? Squeeze If the team is larger, the decisions are slower into the formula the …, the ….
show the answers
Common learner errors
written for your languagein comparison of
✗ In comparison of the old model, this one is lighter
✓ In comparison with the old model…
or Compared with the old model… French en comparaison de and the Russian genitive after sravnenie suggest of. But in English you compare with something: with (or to).
on the contrary instead of by contrast
✗ System A is expensive. On the contrary, System B is cheap
✓ By contrast, System B is cheap
Spanish por el contrario, Italian al contrario and Russian naprotiv mean both "the second one is different" and "no, the opposite is true". In English these are two different expressions. By contrast compares two things. On the contrary rejects what has just been said: — Is it expensive? — On the contrary, it's very cheap.
the same like, similar with
✗ My results are the same like yours → ✓ the same as yours; ✗ similar with → ✓ similar to. German das Gleiche wie and ähnlich wie suggest like; Chinese gēn … yíyàng ("with … the same") and Russian skhozh s suggest with. The prepositions here are fixed: the same as, similar to, different from.
A clause after unlike
✗ Unlike the old system works offline, the new one does not
✓ Unlike the old system, the new one does not work offline
Learners use unlike like whereas, as a conjunction. But unlike is a preposition: only a noun or a pronoun follows it. For two full clauses use whereas: The old system works offline, whereas the new one does not.
Pronunciation
4 minIn a comparison the stress falls on the contrasted words, and the shared part is said more evenly:
The first option is cheaper; ‖ the second is faster. System A works offline, ‖ whereas System B doesn't.
The listener recognises a comparison by the pair of stresses before hearing the conjunction.
Unstressed than and as: cheaper than — /ˈtʃiːpə ðən/, as fast as — /əz ˈfɑːst əz/. The full form /ðæn/ sounds like emphasis.
Stress in the words of comparison: unlike /ʌnˈlaɪk/, compared /kəmˈpeəd/, comparison /kəmˈpærɪsn/, marginally /ˈmɑːdʒɪnəli/. contrast — the noun /ˈkɒntrɑːst/, the verb /kənˈtrɑːst/.
Text
6 minTo: Restaurant managers Re: Choosing a new booking system
We have tested two booking systems: System A and System B. The former has been on the market for ten years; the latter is newer. Both are designed for restaurants of our size, and both run on tablets as well as computers.
The two systems differ mainly in cost, ease of use and reliability. Compared with System A, System B is considerably cheaper: £45 a month, as opposed to £70. It is also far easier to learn. Our staff needed less than an hour to get used to it, whereas System A took most of them a whole afternoon.
Unlike System B, however, System A works offline. If the internet connection fails during a busy evening, we can still see and change bookings. System B, by contrast, simply stops working until the connection comes back. For our older restaurants, where the connection is unreliable, this is a serious drawback.
In terms of customer support, the two are very similar. Neither offers help at weekends, and both answer emails within a day.
The busier the restaurant, the higher the cost of a failure. On balance, therefore, we recommend System A. The extra £25 a month is no more than the cost of two lost bookings.
Exercises
35 min1. Gap fill. compared with, unlike, whereas, by contrast, similarly, the same as, similar to, different from.
- last year, sales are up by a fifth
- the old model, the new one has a built-in camera
- The bus is cheap, the train is fast
- Rents in the centre rose sharply. , rents in the suburbs hardly changed
- The first school has a long waiting list. , the second is full until next year
- My phone is exactly yours — same model, same colour
- The new design is very the old one; I can hardly see the difference
- British spelling is American spelling in many small ways
Show the answers
2. Multiple choice: the measure of the difference. Put in one word or phrase, following the hint.
- System B is cheaper than System A: £45 against £70. (noticeably)
- The new laptop is only heavier — about fifty grams. (by a very small amount)
- The new version is better than the old one — it has all the same problems. (not at all)
- The train is as comfortable as the plane. (far from)
- The second option is as good as the first — choose either. (exactly)
- The new route is as long as the old one — forty kilometres instead of twenty. (two times)
Show the answers
3. Join two sentences into one with the word in brackets.
- The old system needed a server. The new one runs online. (Unlike)
- System A works offline. System B does not. (whereas)
- System A costs £70 a month. System B costs £45. (considerably cheaper)
- The new printer is fast. The old one was equally fast. (just as … as)
- The team is larger. The decisions are slower. (the …, the …)
- The new phone costs £300. The old one cost £600. (half the price)
Show the answers
4. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.
- In comparison of the old model, this one is lighter.
- Unlike System A works offline, System B does not.
- My results are the same like yours.
- The new design is similar with the old one.
- The first flat is in the centre. On the contrary, the second is in the suburbs.
- The larger is the team, the slower are the decisions.
Show the answers
5. Rewrite with the expression in brackets, without changing the meaning.
- The coach is much slower than the train. (nowhere near as … as)
- The new system is as expensive as the old one. (no … than)
- If the interface is simpler, it is better. (the …, the …)
- We chose the train and not the plane. (as opposed to)
- The first hotel was full. The second was full too. (Similarly)
Show the answers
6. Say it in English.
Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence, with the forms of this lesson. 1) The bus does not come often. The train comes every ten minutes. Start with the bus. 2) Prices went up a little. You measure this against last year. 3) The new system costs the same as the old one: it saves you no money at all. 4) A simple interface is good, and a simpler one is even better. Say it as a short formula. 5) The first option almost never fails; the second fails very often. Say it about the second option.
Show the answers
7. Answer in writing
in three or four sentences, building the comparison point by point: which is better for getting around your city — a bike or public transport? You need compared with or unlike, one measure of difference and whereas or by contrast.
Summary
Covered: comparing block by block and point by point; three types of words of comparison — the prepositions compared with, in comparison with, unlike, as opposed to, the conjunctions whereas, while, the adverbs by contrast, similarly, likewise; the same as, similar to, different from, differ; the measure of the difference considerably, marginally, no … than, just as … as, nowhere near as … as; the …, the … without a verb; the former and the latter. Next — lesson 33: describe a product.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Vocabulary for your deck
15 words- compared with /kəmˈpeəd wɪð/ when you compare it with
- in comparison with /ɪn kəmˈpærɪsn wɪð/ when compared with
- unlike /ʌnˈlaɪk/ different from, not in the same way as
- as opposed to /əz əˈpəʊzd tə/ and not, rather than
- by contrast /baɪ ˈkɒntrɑːst/ showing how the second thing is different
- on the contrary /ɒn ðə ˈkɒntrəri/ no — the opposite is true
- similarly /ˈsɪmələli/ in the same way
- likewise /ˈlaɪkwaɪz/ in the same way, also
- differ /ˈdɪfə/ to be different
- marginally /ˈmɑːdʒɪnəli/ by a very small amount
- nowhere near /ˌnəʊweə ˈnɪə/ not at all, far from
- drawback /ˈdrɔːbæk/ a disadvantage
- unreliable /ˌʌnrɪˈlaɪəbl/ that you cannot trust to work well
- offline /ˌɒfˈlaɪn/ without an internet connection
- on balance /ɒn ˈbæləns/ after thinking about all the facts
Writing
Eight to ten sentences: an internal memo comparing two options (two phones, two price plans, two routes, two apps) point by point, not block by block, with a conclusion at the end.
Example
We compared two mobile phone plans for the team. The two plans differ mainly in price and data. Compared with the first plan, the second is considerably cheaper: £12 a month, as opposed to £20. Unlike the first plan, however, it offers only 5 GB of data, whereas most of us use about 8 GB. The first plan, by contrast, has unlimited data. In terms of calls, the plans are very similar. The more we work away from the office, the more data we need. On balance, we recommend the first plan.
Checklist
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional