Review 5 (lessons 25–29)
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Tricky point
12 minWhen you report or argue, you often need to separate the thing itself from everything around it: "money is not the problem in itself; the problem is how it is spent". In English the idea "in itself", "taken on its own" is expressed by three phrases. They are close in meaning, but they differ in style, and as such also has a second meaning.
as such, per se, in itself — "in itself". All three stand right after the word they refer to and narrow the talk down to the thing itself, without what is connected with it:
| The rule is not unfair as such; the problem is how it is applied. | the rule itself is not unfair |
| Money per se is not the issue. | money, taken on its own, is not the issue |
| The idea in itself is good, but the timing is wrong. | the idea on its own is good |
| Technology is not dangerous per se. | technology itself is not dangerous |
Their style is different. in itself (in themselves in the plural) is neutral and fits anywhere. as such is neutral too, but in conversation it more often comes with a negative. per se /ˌpɜː ˈseɪ/ is Latin and bookish; lawyers and scientists like it. In conversation it sounds a little academic.
Why they are needed. These phrases almost always work together with an objection: first you take the blame off the thing itself, then you name the real cause. The pattern "not X in itself, but Y" is one of the most frequent in a balanced text (B2 #25):
| It's not the money per se, it's the way it's spent. | the problem is not money, but how it is spent |
| Tourism in itself is not the problem; mass tourism is. | tourism is fine; mass tourism is the trouble |
Without the phrase, Money is not the problem sounds like an argument against the idea itself. With it, you agree that the question matters and make clear where exactly the difficulty is.
Position and number. The phrase stands right after the noun or at the end of the part with be: Money per se is not the issue = Money is not the issue per se. as such and per se do not change. But in itself agrees with what it refers to: The idea in itself, but The rules in themselves are fair — about several things.
"There is no … as such". After no and not, as such means "in the strict sense of the word":
| There is no plan as such, just a few ideas. | no real plan, only a few ideas |
| He isn't a doctor as such, but he has medical training. | not exactly a doctor, in the strict sense |
The second meaning of as such — "in this role". Here such points to the noun that has just been named. as such = "being that, in that capacity":
| He is the manager, and as such he signs all contracts. | as the manager, he signs the contracts |
| The paintings are very old and, as such, must be handled with care. | because they are old, they need careful handling |
A test: put the noun you named in place of such. as the manager — the meaning is the same, so the use is correct.
Careful. Many people write As such, at the start of a sentence in the meaning "therefore", when there is no noun before it: The tests were incomplete. As such, the results are unreliable. This is not a mistake: many native speakers say and write it. But in strict writing — in an essay, a report, an exam — this As such is avoided, and editors correct it: such has nothing to point to here. Therefore, or As a result, (B2 #23) are safer.
Compare.
| The museum is free, but the exhibitions as such are small. | the exhibitions themselves |
| She is the head of the school and, as such, is responsible for safety. | in her role as head |
Don't say this. ✗ There is no plan such as → ✓ There is no plan as such. such as means "for example" (B2 #23), as such means "in itself". The word order changes the meaning.
Check yourself. Money is not where the problem lies — only money, without everything around it: how do you say it, starting with The problem is not? Which of the three — as such, per se, in itself — is the most bookish? What does as such point to in She is a lawyer and, as such, she knows the risks?
show the answers
Exercises on lessons 25–29
35 min1. Mixed gap fill. One word or phrase in each gap. Where nothing is needed, put —.
- Rent has risen, wages have not
- I like the idea, it won't work
- The result was positive, small
- The delay resulted higher costs
- The main reason the delay was the weather
- inflation is a sustained increase in prices
- It was such unusual request
- We need to a decision by Friday
- The client two concerns at the meeting
- The author rightly out that the figures are incomplete
Show the answers
2. Error correction. There is one mistake in each sentence.
- Whereas it was raining, we went out.
- Despite that the price was high, we bought it.
- The new tax led to raise prices.
- The changes affected on our sales.
- Computer is a machine that processes data.
- We did a mistake in the invoice.
- The article discusses about remote work.
- There is no plan such as.
Show the answers
3. Transform following the prompt in brackets. Write the whole sentence.
- Although I respect her, I can't agree. (much as)
- Prices went up because of a shortage of oil. (The rise in prices … result from)
- We considered Paris and Rome. Rome was cheaper. (the latter)
- The team started the project in May. (formal: commence)
- "Prices may fall next year," the report says. (The report / suggest)
- Money is not the problem in itself. (per se)
Show the answers
4. Join the two sentences into one with the word in brackets.
- My brother loves the city. I prefer the countryside. (whereas)
- The flight was delayed. We arrived on time. (despite the fact that)
- The strike stopped the trains. + This caused traffic jams. (which in turn)
- A thermometer is an instrument. + It measures temperature. (that)
- He is the director. + In that role he signs all contracts. (as such)
Show the answers
5. Matching. Word → what it is for.
- whereas
- much as
- result from
- the latter
- claims that
Show the answers
6. Say it in English.
Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence, with the forms of lessons 25–29. 1) The plan is expensive. All the same, it is the best of all. 2) There was a delay, and because of it the costs went up. Start with The delay. 3) Say what we mean by inflation: prices go up, and they keep going up for a long time. Start with By. 4) You are sorry to say that your team will not be ready by the agreed date. Start with I'm afraid we. 5) Money is not where the problem lies — only money, without everything around it.
Show the answers
Summary
Covered: lessons 25–29 in full and "in itself" with three phrases — as such, per se, in itself; as such in the meaning "in this role" and care with As such in the meaning "therefore". Next — lesson 31: describe data.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Mini production
Talk aloud and then write down ten sentences — a balanced analysis of a disputed decision in your town or at work. You need contrast and concession, a chain of cause with three links, one definition, two or three collocations from lesson 28, a report of someone else's opinion with a frame verb and one as such, per se or in itself.
Checklist before lesson 31:
- contrast with whereas or while, concession with although or much as? no clause after albeit?
- is the direction of result in / result from right? a noun after lead to? the reason for?
- general concepts without the? does the definition have a general word? such a in the singular?
- make for a result, do for an activity? formal words only in the letter?
- present tense about a text? no discusses about or according to me?
- as such after the noun, not such as?
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional