Škakljiva tema ~47 min od osnove preostalo

Ponavljanje 5 (lekcije 25–29)

Započni lekciju Jezgro 47 min · koraci: 3 · opciono: +1

Deklarisano vreme jezgra. Dva bloka jezgra nemaju broj, pa je stvarna lekcija duža od ovog zbira.

Škakljiva tema

12 min

U prepričavanju i u raspravi često treba odvojiti samu pojavu od onoga što je okružuje: „novac sam po sebi nije problem, problem je u tome kako se troši“. Srpsko „sam po sebi“ i „kao takav“ prevode se trima izrazima. Oni su bliski po smislu, ali se razlikuju po stilu, a as such ima i drugo značenje.

as such, per se, in itself — „sam po sebi“. Sva tri stoje odmah posle reči na koju se odnose i sužavaju razgovor na sam predmet, bez onoga što je s njim povezano:

The rule is not unfair as such; the problem is how it is applied. Pravilo samo po sebi nije nepravedno.
Money per se is not the issue. Novac kao takav nije problem.
The idea in itself is good, but the timing is wrong. Ideja je sama po sebi dobra.
Technology is not dangerous per se. Tehnologija sama po sebi nije opasna.

Stil im je različit. in itself (in themselves u množini) je neutralno i pristaje svuda. as such je takođe neutralno, ali u razgovoru češće stoji uz odricanje. per se /ˌpɜː ˈseɪ/ je latinsko, knjiško, vole ga pravnici i naučnici. U razgovoru zvuči pomalo učeno.

Čemu služe. Ovi izrazi skoro uvek idu u paru sa prigovorom: najpre se krivica skine sa samog predmeta, zatim se imenuje pravi uzrok. Šema „nije X sam po sebi, nego Y“ jedna je od najčešćih u uravnoteženom tekstu (B2 #25):

It's not the money per se, it's the way it's spent. Nije stvar u novcu kao takvom, nego u tome kako se troši.
Tourism in itself is not the problem; mass tourism is. Turizam sam po sebi nije nevolja — nevolja je masovni turizam.

Bez izraza rečenica Money is not the problem zvuči kao spor sa samom idejom. Sa njim se slažeš da je pitanje važno i precizno kažeš gde je teškoća.

Mesto i broj. Izraz stoji odmah posle imenice ili na kraju dela sa be: Money per se is not the issue = Money is not the issue per se. as such i per se se ne menjaju. A in itself se slaže sa onim o čemu je reč: The idea in itself, ali The rules in themselves are fair — o više predmeta.

„Kao takvog nema“. Posle no i not izraz as such znači „u strogom smislu reči“:

There is no plan as such, just a few ideas. Plana kao takvog nema, ima samo nekoliko ideja.
He isn't a doctor as such, but he has medical training. Nije baš lekar u strogom smislu.

Drugo značenje as such — „u tom svojstvu“. Ovde such upućuje na imenicu koja je upravo pomenuta. as such = „kao takav, budući da je to“ — isto kao srpsko „kao takav“ u rečenici „on je direktor i kao takav potpisuje ugovore“:

He is the manager, and as such he signs all contracts. On je upravnik i u tom svojstvu potpisuje ugovore.
The paintings are very old and, as such, must be handled with care. Kao stare, zahtevaju pažljivo rukovanje.

Provera: umesto such stavi pomenutu imenicu. as the manager — smisao je isti, znači da je upotreba tačna.

Pažljivo. Mnogi pišu As such, na početku rečenice u značenju „zato“, iako ispred njega nema nikakve imenice: The tests were incomplete. As such, the results are unreliable. To nije greška: tako govore i pišu mnogi izvorni govornici. Ali u strogom pisanju — u eseju, izveštaju, na ispitu — takvo As such se izbegava, i urednici ga ispravljaju: such ovde nema na šta da uputi. Sigurnije je Therefore, ili As a result, (B2 #23).

Uporedi.

The museum is free, but the exhibitions as such are small. same izložbe
She is the head of the school and, as such, is responsible for safety. u svojstvu direktorke

Tako se ne kaže. ✗ There is no plan such as → ✓ There is no plan as such. such as — „na primer“ (B2 #23), as such — „kao takav“. Red reči menja smisao.

Proveri se. Kako reći „Problem nije u novcu kao takvom“? Koji od tri izraza — as such, per se, in itself — je najknjiškiji? Na šta upućuje as such u She is a lawyer and, as such, she knows the risks?

prikaži odgovore
The problem is not money as such (ili money per se, money in itself); per se; na reč lawyer: „kao advokatica“.
Oglas

Vežbe za lekcije 25–29

35 min

1. Mešovito popunjavanje. Jedna reč ili izraz u svaku prazninu. Gde ništa nije potrebno, stavi —.

  1. Rent has risen, wages have not
  2. I like the idea, it won't work
  3. The result was positive, small
  4. The delay resulted higher costs
  5. The main reason the delay was the weather
  6. inflation is a sustained increase in prices
  7. It was such unusual request
  8. We need to a decision by Friday
  9. The client two concerns at the meeting
  10. The author rightly out that the figures are incomplete
Prikaži odgovore
whereas / while / but; Much as / Although / Even though / While / Though; albeit / though; in; for; —; an; make / take; raised; points

2. Pronalaženje greške. Pronađi grešku i ispravi je. U svakoj rečenici je jedna.

  1. Whereas it was raining, we went out.
  2. Despite that the price was high, we bought it.
  3. The new tax led to raise prices.
  4. The changes affected on our sales.
  5. Computer is a machine that processes data.
  6. We did a mistake in the invoice.
  7. The article discusses about remote work.
  8. There is no plan such as.
Prikaži odgovore
Although it was raining, we went out / Even though it was raining, we went out / Though it was raining, we went out / While it was raining, we went out; Despite the fact that the price was high, we bought it / Although the price was high, we bought it / Despite the high price, we bought it; The new tax led to higher prices / The new tax led to a rise in prices / The new tax led to prices rising / The new tax led companies to raise prices / The new tax led shops to raise prices; The changes affected our sales / The changes had an effect on our sales; A computer is a machine that processes data / Computers are machines that process data; We made a mistake in the invoice; The article discusses remote work; There is no plan as such

3. Pretvori prema podsticaju iz zagrade. Piši celu rečenicu.

  1. Although I respect her, I can't agree. (much as)
  2. Prices went up because of a shortage of oil. (The rise in prices … result from)
  3. We considered Paris and Rome. Rome was cheaper. (the latter)
  4. The team started the project in May. (zvanično: commence)
  5. "Prices may fall next year," the report says. (The report / suggest)
  6. Money is not the problem in itself. (per se)
Prikaži odgovore
Much as I respect her, I can't agree / Much as I respect her, I cannot agree; The rise in prices resulted from a shortage of oil / The rise in prices resulted from the shortage of oil; We considered Paris and Rome. The latter was cheaper; The team commenced the project in May; The report suggests that prices may fall next year; Money per se is not the problem / Money is not the problem per se

4. Spoji dve rečenice u jednu rečju iz zagrade.

  1. My brother loves the city. I prefer the countryside. (whereas)
  2. The flight was delayed. We arrived on time. (despite the fact that)
  3. The strike stopped the trains. + This caused traffic jams. (which in turn)
  4. A thermometer is an instrument. + It measures temperature. (that)
  5. He is the director. + In that role he signs all contracts. (as such)
Prikaži odgovore
My brother loves the city, whereas I prefer the countryside; Despite the fact that the flight was delayed, we arrived on time / We arrived on time despite the fact that the flight was delayed; The strike stopped the trains, which in turn caused traffic jams; A thermometer is an instrument that measures temperature; He is the director, and as such he signs all contracts / He is the director, and as such, he signs all contracts / He is the director and, as such, signs all contracts

5. Povezivanje. Reč → čemu služi.

  1. whereas
  2. much as
  3. result from
  4. the latter
  5. claims that
Prikaži odgovore
whereas — uporediti dve činjenice; much as — priznati svoje osećanje i usprotiviti se; result from — navesti uzrok posle posledice; the latter — drugi od dva; claims that — preneti spornu tvrdnju

6. Prevedi na engleski.

1) Iako je plan skup, najbolji je od svih. 2) Kašnjenje je dovelo do rasta troškova. 3) Pod inflacijom se podrazumeva postojan rast cena. 4) Bojim se da nećemo ispoštovati rok. 5) Novac sam po sebi nije problem.

Prikaži odgovore
Although the plan is expensive, it is the best of all / The plan is the best of all, albeit expensive / Even though the plan is expensive, it is the best of all / Though the plan is expensive, it is the best of all; The delay led to higher costs / The delay resulted in higher costs / The delay led to an increase in costs / The delay led to a rise in costs; By inflation we mean a sustained increase in prices / Inflation is understood as a sustained rise in prices / By inflation we mean a sustained rise in prices / Inflation is understood as a sustained increase in prices / Inflation is defined as a sustained increase in prices / Inflation is defined as a sustained rise in prices; I'm afraid we won't meet the deadline / I'm afraid we won't be able to meet the deadline / I'm afraid we won't make the deadline; Money in itself is not the problem / Money as such is not the problem / Money per se is not the problem
Oglas

Rezime

Obrađeno: lekcije 25–29 u celini i „sam po sebi“ preko tri izraza — as such, per se, in itself; as such u značenju „u tom svojstvu“ i oprez sa As such u značenju „zato“. Sledi lekcija 31: opisati podatke.

Kraj osnove

Lekcija se računa kao završena kada se urade vežbe. Sve nakon ovoga je opciono.

Lekcija 139

opciono

Samostalni govor i pisanje

Ispričaj naglas i zapiši deset rečenica — uravnoteženu analizu sporne odluke u tvom gradu ili na poslu. Potrebni su suprotnost i dopuštanje, uzročni lanac od tri karike, jedna definicija, dve-tri kolokacije iz lekcije 28, prepričavanje tuđeg mišljenja sa glagolom okvira i jedno as such, per se ili in itself.

Kontrolna lista pre lekcije 31:

  • suprotnost preko whereas ili while, dopuštanje preko although ili much as? posle albeit nema rečenice sa glagolom?
  • smer result in / result from je tačan? posle lead to — imenica? the reason for?
  • opšti pojmovi bez the? definicija ima rodni pojam? such a u jednini?
  • make za rezultat, do za posao? zvanične reči — samo u pismu?
  • o tekstu — sadašnje vreme? nema discusses about ni according to me?
  • as such posle imenice, a ne such as?
Nacrt je sačuvan na ovom uređaju

Imate ideju za novu funkciju?

Pošalji ideju
Oglas
Oglas