Edit a sentence
I can find agreement mistakes in my own text and put the punctuation marks in a complex sentence.
Declared core time. Two of the core blocks carry no figure at all, so the real lesson is longer than this sum.
Grammar
20 minA spellchecker will not find two kinds of mistakes that give a foreigner away at once: a verb in the wrong number (The list of changes are attached) and commas placed by the rules of another language. Neither mistake stops the reader from understanding the text, but the reader notices them from the first paragraph. Today — the rules you use to proofread your own text before you send it.
Agreement: the verb looks at the main word of the subject. There is one rule: find the main word in the subject and make the verb agree with it, not with the nearest noun. The traps appear where the main word is hard to see.
| trap | correct |
|---|---|
| a long group between the subject and the verb | The list of the changes is attached. The quality of the photos is poor. |
| each, every, everyone (A2 #14) | Each of the rooms has a bathroom. Everyone in the offices has been told. |
| the number of — one number | The number of complaints has fallen. |
| a number of — "several" | A number of customers have complained. |
| singular words that end in -s | The news is good. Economics is hard. |
| uncountable nouns | The information is useful. Your advice was helpful. |
| an -ing form or a clause as the subject | Checking the figures takes time. What we need is time (B2 #16). |
| there is / there are | There are two problems. |
In conversation people often say There's two problems; in writing — There are two problems.
Collective nouns in British English. staff, team, government, company, family can agree in either number. Singular — when it is one whole: The team is the best in the league. Plural — when you think of the people: The team are all ready. Neither is a mistake, but within one text the choice must be the same. police is always plural: The police are investigating. data in a business text is usually singular (The data shows), in a scientific one — plural (The data show).
Punctuation: where a comma is needed.
| rule | example |
|---|---|
| a clause at the front — a comma after it | When the report arrived, we changed the plan. |
| a long introductory phrase — a comma | After three months of testing, we chose System A. |
| a non-defining clause — between commas (B1 #17) | My brother, who lives in Leeds, is a doctor. |
| a linking adverb at the start — a comma (B2 #23) | However, the costs are high. |
| a list — commas | time, money and patience |
In a list, British English usually puts no comma before and; with it (time, money, and patience) is also correct, as long as you do it throughout the text.
Where there is no comma. This is the main difference from languages such as German, Russian or Polish, which put a comma before every subordinate clause.
| rule | ✓ |
|---|---|
| a clause at the end — no comma | We changed the plan when the report arrived. Let me know if you have questions. |
| before that (A2 #33) and an indirect question | I think that it works. Could you tell me where it is? |
| a defining clause — no commas | The report that you sent is incomplete. |
| between the subject and the verb | The list of the changes we discussed is attached. |
In German, Russian or Polish a comma always goes before a relative clause ("who", "which"). In English it goes there only if the clause is non-defining, that is, you can cross it out and it is still clear what is meant: My brother, who lives in Leeds, is a doctor (I have only one brother). If the clause says which of the things is meant, there are no commas: The people who work here are friendly.
Comma splice — two sentences joined by a comma. ✗ Costs rose, profits fell. In French, German, Russian or Chinese this is normal; in English it is not: a comma does not join two full sentences. Three ways to correct it:
| way | example |
|---|---|
| a full stop | Costs rose. Profits fell. |
| a conjunction after the comma | Costs rose, but profits fell. |
| a semicolon | Costs rose; profits fell. |
A semicolon links two sentences that are close in meaning. It also goes before however, therefore, moreover if the two sentences merge into one: The figures are good; however, we must be careful (B2 #23).
A colon comes after a complete sentence and opens a list or an explanation: We have two options: to wait or to cancel. The reason is simple: nobody tested it. After include, are and similar words a colon is not usually used: The options are to wait or to cancel.
How to proofread. In each sentence find the subject and its main word, and check the verb. Then go through every comma: does it stand between two full sentences? before that, if, a defining clause? Read the text aloud: a punctuation mark usually stands where your voice makes a pause.
Examples:
| The list of the items is on the desk. | the main word is list — one list |
| Each of the students has a copy. | the main word is each — every single student |
| The number of applications has doubled. | there are twice as many applications as before |
| The news from the factory is worrying. | news is singular, though it ends in -s |
| If you have any questions, please call me. | the clause comes first — a comma after it |
| Please call me if you have any questions. | the clause comes second — no comma |
| The man who called yesterday said he would come back. | which man? the one who called — no commas |
| Our designer, who joined in May, will present the layout. | we have one designer; the clause only adds information |
| The office was closed, so we went home. | two full sentences — a comma and a conjunction |
| We need three things: time, money and patience. | a colon after a complete sentence opens a list |
Don't say this. ✗ Each of the rooms have a bathroom → ✓ Each of the rooms has a bathroom. The main word is each, "every one", not rooms.
Check yourself. The number of users ___ (be) growing — is or are? Do you need a comma in I think that it works and in When it rains we stay at home? How do you correct I called twice, nobody answered?
show the answers
Common learner errors
written for your languageComma splice
✗ The office was closed, we went home
✓ The office was closed, so we went home
or The office was closed. We went home. In French, German, Russian and Chinese a comma between two full sentences is normal. In English it is one of the most noticeable mistakes in writing.
Commas around a defining clause
✗ The report, that you sent me, is incomplete
✓ The report that you sent me is incomplete
German, Polish and Russian always put commas around a relative clause, and the hand adds them out of habit. In English commas change the meaning, and after that there are none at all.
A comma before that, if or a question word
✗ Please let me know, if you have any questions, ✗ Could you tell me, where the meeting is? → ✓ no comma. German Sagen Sie mir, wo… and Russian skazhite, gde… require a comma before every subordinate clause. In English a clause after the main one is not separated by a comma.
Agreement with the nearest word
✗ The quality of the photos are poor
✓ is
The nearest noun, photos, is plural, and the verb follows it. The main word is quality.
news, information, advice in the plural
✗ The news are good
✗ informations
✗ advices
✓ The news is good
information, advice. French les informations, des conseils, Spanish las noticias, German Ratschläge are plural, and the plural is carried into English. These English words are uncountable: a piece of news, some advice.
there is before a plural
✗ There is two problems with the plan
✓ There are two problems
French il y a, Spanish hay and German es gibt never change. In English the verb agrees with what follows.
Pronunciation
4 minYou can hear punctuation. A comma is a short pause, a semicolon a longer one, a full stop the longest, with the voice falling:
Costs rose ‖ but profits fell. Costs rose ‖‖ profits fell.
A non-defining clause sounds different from a defining one. A non-defining clause is set off by pauses and said lower and faster, like brackets. A defining clause comes without pauses, in one piece with the main word:
My brother ‖ who lives in Leeds ‖ is a doctor. — only one brother My brother who lives in Leeds is a doctor. — several brothers; this is the one in Leeds
Check your text by ear: if, when you read aloud, no pause comes where the comma stands, the comma is probably not needed.
semicolon /ˌsemiˈkəʊlən/, colon /ˈkəʊlən/, comma /ˈkɒmə/.
Text
6 minBefore editing:
Dear Ms Patel, thank you for your email, the list of changes you asked for are attached. Everyone in the design team have checked it and the data from the last survey supports our proposal. The news about the budget are good however, the number of shops in the trial have been reduced to six. Our designer who joined us in May, will present the new layout at the meeting, that you suggested. When you have read the document please let me know, if you have any questions.
After editing:
Dear Ms Patel,
Thank you for your email. The list of changes you asked for is attached. Everyone in the design team has checked it, and the data from the last survey supports our proposal. The news about the budget is good; however, the number of shops in the trial has been reduced to six. Our designer, who joined us in May, will present the new layout at the meeting that you suggested. When you have read the document, please let me know if you have any questions.
Exercises
35 min1. Gap fill: the verb in the right number.
- The list of changes (be) attached
- Each of the rooms (have) its own bathroom
- The number of complaints (have) fallen
- A number of customers (have) complained
- The news from the factory (be) worrying
- There (be) two problems with the plan
- Checking all the figures (take) a lot of time
- The police (be) looking into the matter
Show the answers
2. Rewrite, adding the commas that are needed.
- When the report arrived we changed the plan.
- My sister who lives in Leeds is a nurse. (I have only one sister)
- Although the figures are good the board is worried.
- If you have any questions please call me.
- Our new manager who started in May has already made changes. (there is only one manager)
- We need three things: time money and patience.
Show the answers
3. Correct the punctuation: remove the commas that are not needed.
- I think, that the plan will work.
- Please let me know, if you need anything.
- Everyone, who wants to come, should tell me by Friday.
- The list of the changes we discussed last week, is attached.
- Could you tell me, where the meeting is?
Show the answers
4. Correct the comma splice: join the parts with the conjunction in brackets or separate them with a full stop.
- The office was closed, we went home. (so)
- Costs rose, profits fell. (but)
- I called twice, nobody answered. (but)
- The train was late, I missed the meeting. (full stop)
- The figures are good, however, we must be careful. (full stop)
Show the answers
5. Rewrite with a semicolon instead of a full stop.
- Costs rose. Profits fell.
- The figures are good. However, we must be careful.
- Some staff work from home. Others come in every day.
- The plan is cheap. Moreover, it is quick.
Show the answers
6. Correct both mistakes in each sentence.
- The quality of the photos are poor, we need new ones.
- Everyone in the offices have received the news, that the branch will close.
- The man, who called yesterday, said, that he would come back.
- When the news arrive we will tell the staff.
Show the answers
7. Say it in English
— watch the commas. Each line describes a situation in simple words. Say it in one sentence. 1) A colleague sent you a report, and some parts are missing. Tell them. Start with The report. 2) You have only one brother. Say that he is a doctor and add, as extra information, that he lives in Leeds. Start with My brother. 3) The news is good, and here is why: the managers have approved the budget. Use a colon, and the passive for the budget. 4) You don't know when the meeting starts. Ask a colleague politely, with an indirect question.
Show the answers
Summary
Covered: agreement with the main word of the subject; the traps each, the number of and a number of, news, information, an -ing form as the subject, there are; collective nouns in British English; a comma after a clause at the front and around a non-defining clause; no comma before that, if, an indirect question and a defining clause; the comma splice and three ways to correct it; the semicolon and the colon; proofreading by ear. Next — lesson 35: the project.
End of the core
The lesson counts as done once the exercises are done. Everything after this is optional.
optional
Vocabulary for your deck
14 words- proofread /ˈpruːfriːd/ to read a text to find and correct mistakes
- comma /ˈkɒmə/ the mark , in a sentence
- semicolon /ˌsemiˈkəʊlən/ the mark ; between two closely linked sentences
- colon /ˈkəʊlən/ the mark : before a list or an explanation
- full stop /fʊl ˈstɒp/ the mark . at the end of a sentence
- typo /ˈtaɪpəʊ/ a small mistake in typing
- draft /drɑːft/ a first version of a text, not yet finished
- revise /rɪˈvaɪz/ to change a text to make it better
- attach /əˈtætʃ/ to add a file to an email
- consistent /kənˈsɪstənt/ always the same, done in the same way
- survey /ˈsɜːveɪ/ a set of questions that you ask many people
- punctuation /ˌpʌŋktʃuˈeɪʃn/ the marks used in writing, such as commas and full stops
- layout /ˈleɪaʊt/ the way the parts of a page, a room or a design are arranged
- edit /ˈedɪt/ to correct and improve a text
Writing
Take your letter from B2 #21 or B2 #23 (or any English text of your own of 10–12 sentences) and edit it: find the main word of the subject in each sentence, check every comma and read the text aloud. Write down separately what you had to correct.
Example of editing
The results of the survey shows, that most of our customers is happy with the service, the managers are less sure. → The results of the survey show that most of our customers are happy with the service. The managers are less sure.
Checklist
Practise this lesson in the other sections
Got a feature idea?
⚑ optional